PackersRS
Cheesehead
What do you think? Yes or No? No questions asked, but if you want to, better
Ahealthy in his prime Marino with that cannon arm is a tough call but a leg brace wearing still a cannon throwin Arm Marino No. I would say Peyton Manning is the best QB I have ever seen to tell you the truth but you can't discard Bradshaw, Aikmen,Brady, Elway or Marino even though Marino accomplished little compared(team wise) to the rest. Brett Favre has earned his way into that group and that is saying alot.Marino Better than Favre or not?
IMO no. But that's not the pollMarino Better than Favre or not?
I have to agree that Peyton Manning will probably be the best all time QB when all is said and done. Granted I don't know much about the older QB's, but but Manning has everything going for him. Almost never injured, stat master, already has a ring, family history...he's an icon.
Why do you say that? I doubt being the next Brett Favre is his goal. He is the best in NFL today and has been for 6-7 years IMO. Then I would have to with Tom Brady. Brett Favre is a first ballot HOF as will Peyton so your bias towards Favre is overwhelming. Peyton Manning has his own Legacy working just fine for him.Peyton is certainly solid, but I think he'd even admit he is no Brett Favre, for reasons we've covered numerous times.
IMHO Tom Brady is better than Manning. When he had the weapons to match Manning's stats, he surpassed him. He's also more clutch, had to overcome a lot more, as has the better wifeWhy do you say that? I doubt being the next Brett Favre is his goal. He is the best in NFL today and has been for 6-7 years IMO. Then I would have to with Tom Brady. Brett Favre is a first ballot HOF as will Peyton so your bias towards Favre is overwhelming. Peyton Manning has his own Legacy working just fine for him.
Why do you say that? I doubt being the next Brett Favre is his goal. He is the best in NFL today and has been for 6-7 years IMO. Then I would have to with Tom Brady. Brett Favre is a first ballot HOF as will Peyton so your bias towards Favre is overwhelming. Peyton Manning has his own Legacy working just fine for him.
Fair enough can't argue with your logic. Either way your in good shapeIMHO Tom Brady is better than Manning. When he had the weapons to match Manning's stats, he surpassed him. He's also more clutch, had to overcome a lot more, as has the better wife
In all seriousness, I'd rather take Brady as my QB than Manning. Of course, the difference is barely palpable...
Why do you say that? I doubt being the next Brett Favre is his goal. He is the best in NFL today and has been for 6-7 years IMO. Then I would have to with Tom Brady. Brett Favre is a first ballot HOF as will Peyton so your bias towards Favre is overwhelming. Peyton Manning has his own Legacy working just fine for him.
Your wron we all know the best was TJ Rubly
IMHO Tom Brady is better than Manning. When he had the weapons to match Manning's stats, he surpassed him. He's also more clutch, had to overcome a lot more, as has the better wife
In all seriousness, I'd rather take Brady as my QB than Manning. Of course, the difference is barely palpable...
You can only judge what you have so your what if's and what not's do not belong in this conversation. Peyton Manning is the smartest and well prepared QB in the NFL week in and week out as shown in his numbers.First, his feet are WAY TOO HAPPY. Even if that's not a negative, he looks like a freak out there, so that's gotta be worth negative points - LOL.
Peyton's good, but he's never had a poor O-line with the exception if maybe his first season or two. He's also benefited from an unbelievable offensive scheme, although he pretty much runs the show now.
If you watch both Favre and Manning under intense pressure (like Manning used to get years back in all those losses to New England), you'll discover what I'm talking about.
I think this is what I keep saying, but not loud enough. The Brady's and Mannings - they're good, but they're not Favre good. They can't duplicate their efforts on any, random NFL team. Favre dominates in Green Bay, New York (until injury, he was leading the league in passer rating) and now Minnesota. The problem is, we'll probably never get to see Manning in another city or Brady for that matter. Favre's just a special kinda cat.
Bobby Douglas of the Bears and The General Bobby Lee of the Vikes back in the dayHe was no Blair Kiel.
Favre has screwed the pooch too many times to be the best.
Dan is the man. Never had a good enough defense as a team to get a ring, though.