Rookie Impact 2025

El Guapo

Cheesehead
Joined
Dec 7, 2011
Messages
7,373
Reaction score
2,827
Location
Land 'O Lakes
Leaving out Matthew Golden (who should be an instant contributor), which rookies do you think will have the greatest impact and why?

RndPlayerPosition
1Matthew GoldenWR
2Anthony BeltonOT
3Savion WilliamsWR
4Barryn SorrellEdge
5Collin OliverEdge
6Warren BrinsonDT
7Micah RobinsonCB
7John WilliamsOT
UDFAAmar JohnsonRB
UDFAJalen WhiteRB
UDFAJulian FlemingWR
UDFAJ.J. LippeOG
UDFATyler CooperOG
UDFABrant BanksT
UDFANazir StackhouseST
UDFAJamon Dumas-JohnsonLB
UDFAKahzir BrownCB
UDFATyron HerringCB
UDFAJonathan BaldwinST

Disclaimer - The UDFA list is from the draft. It may have changed slightly since then
 

AmishMafia

Cheesehead
Joined
Sep 27, 2010
Messages
7,907
Reaction score
3,180
Location
PENDING
Belton will have a tough time unsettling any of the likely starters. There will be 1 starters worthy player already on the bench.

Savion Williams is such a unique talent. I could see him getting 7-10 plays per game towards the end of the season and a few dynamic big plays. They always garner more attention, so that is my bet.
 

gopkrs

Cheesehead
Joined
May 12, 2014
Messages
7,781
Reaction score
2,742
Belton will have a tough time unsettling any of the likely starters. There will be 1 starters worthy player already on the bench.

Savion Williams is such a unique talent. I could see him getting 7-10 plays per game towards the end of the season and a few dynamic big plays. They always garner more attention, so that is my bet.
I thought when we drafted him that he had a problem with drops. Is that right?
 

Pkrjones

Cheesehead
Joined
Jul 3, 2014
Messages
4,945
Reaction score
2,811
Location
Mesquite, NV
I would like it if Belton made a splash in TC & warranted some playing time at RG... but cracking the starting lineup will be tough.

Agree that MLF can work in a few manufactured touches for Savion Williams. He's supposedly electric with the ball in his hands, so can see him as occasional jet-sweep guy and/or bubble screen guy (assuming he can reliably catch it). IF he becomes punt returner he's my choice, but...

Hoping Nazir Stackhouse fills the rotational run-stopper role on short yardage and run downs. Final answer: Stackhouse.
 

tynimiller

Cheesehead
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
18,883
Reaction score
8,536
"Impact" is sadly something I've learned is quite dependent on the person...and I'd argue many are just unrealistic on what making an impact as a rookie is...

To be fair Gute and GB has been on an absolute TEAR when it comes to contributing rookies of late for years really...that said I'll just run quickly through some of note IMO:

Golden - I think folks likely need to realize we have some guys established in the system (Doubs, Reed, Wicks) make the things I'm hearing about Golden putting up 1,000 yards really needs some reality injected into it. Watson is even going to come back at some point as well...but don't get me wrong I think as a rookie Golden likely would shock me at all with a line of like 6TD, 65Rec and 700 yards. He's going to be a high level contributor I think in a few games...could totally see like 50% of his production coming in just four games...just the type of player mixed with roster and rookie type thing I wouldn't be shocked of.

Belton - I mentioned it when we drafted Tom, he CAN start year 1, but the roster may not allow it out the gate. I personally think they need to decide the LT of the future, if it is Walker Morgan is your other guard and Belton has ZERO chance of starting this year as Banks and Morgan are the guards. BUT I personally envision Morgan is the LT of the future and we could see Belton push for RG responsibility. To me realistic impact Belton will have is when we have an injury happen and he steps in and contributes.

Savion - I love Savion but overdrafted and really is that RB playing WR type guy (better, taller version of Ty Montgomery IMO). I think like Ty Montgomery Savion will contribute relatively early and do well with what he is asked to do. He will be impactful with the limited calls structured for him.

Sorrell - Sorrell IMO besides Belton is arguably the one guy I circle as both mentally and physically ready for the NFL and I could envision him truly being that stable depth guy that hits 30-40% of the defensive snaps purely because of his consistency...and an edge fourth rounder to be being talked of that level I think is massively impactful relatively.

Oliver - Oliver is part off ball part outside...that I think takes time to really find his groove but there is a DUDE in there potentially for sure.

Nazir - I have not been more sure of an UDFA filling a role on a team more than Nazir...we have no one IMO that can help fill the Slaton departure along with Clark likely playing more 1T.

**Honorable Mentions - we have some incredible safeties but that 5th spot to me is up for grabs and if injury would strike don't be shocked if Jonathan Baldwin gets called up and delivers....similar to Jamon Dumas Johnson....Quay injured right now has to have JDJ licking his chops for the chance it may provide.
 
OP
OP
El Guapo

El Guapo

Cheesehead
Joined
Dec 7, 2011
Messages
7,373
Reaction score
2,827
Location
Land 'O Lakes
I'm on board with Sorrell. I think purely because of the lack of impact players at EDGE, that he has the potential to make the biggest impact. Add on what you mentioned, that he seems to have the mental and physical tools to compete immediately.

I also hope that somebody (multiple guys actually) comes out of nowhere to be the impact guy.
 

tynimiller

Cheesehead
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
18,883
Reaction score
8,536
I'm on board with Sorrell. I think purely because of the lack of impact players at EDGE, that he has the potential to make the biggest impact. Add on what you mentioned, that he seems to have the mental and physical tools to compete immediately.

I also hope that somebody (multiple guys actually) comes out of nowhere to be the impact guy.

I know some might disagree, and you might even but I sense you might be like me. If you told me I had to pick a guy from our entire draft list not named Golden to be the most likely to be that consistent solid but not great guy contributing this year in subtle or small ways even when no one notices Barryn is that dude - JUST like the guy who he is likely replacing after this year I said would be and he has been in Kingsley Enagbare...on draft night buddy asked what I thought of Sorrell...I said he was an end of Day2 at most type guy and my player comp was "A more mature and athletic Enagbare, but slightly shorter length".

And in truth what Enagbare has been is incredible for when he was drafted - which in my opinion was a STEAL as many know I had him at one time in that draft cycle nearly a backend first rounder and ended up as a second round grade for me. The crazy thing is Enagbare had 18 DEs (per pro football reference - there will be some additional guys listed as a LB likely) picked ahead of him that year...9 of which were picked before even the third round.

He currently has produced less sacks than only 6 of those 18 - Travon Walker, Aidan Hutchinson, Kayvon Thibodeaux, George Karlaftis, Arnold Ebiketie and Boye Mafe. He also has more solo tackles to his credit than all but 5 of his entire DE draft class. Dude overshot his spot in every way possible.

If Barryn shows he can be a similar level guy Gute will have yet again hit an additional homerun on Day 3
 

gopkrs

Cheesehead
Joined
May 12, 2014
Messages
7,781
Reaction score
2,742
I don't know if it was the camera angle but it looked like Savion has humongous hands
 
OP
OP
El Guapo

El Guapo

Cheesehead
Joined
Dec 7, 2011
Messages
7,373
Reaction score
2,827
Location
Land 'O Lakes
He's a big guy with big hands, so I'm okay with him not having top end speed as long as he uses his height effectively.
 

Members online

No members online now.
Top