2026 Roster Thread - Semi-Live

tynimiller

Cheesehead
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
18,600
Reaction score
8,289
Poppa asked if I'd start a new thread as the one I was using had a whole 50 pages worth of 2025 discussions and it likely will confuse folks.

So like normal this will be the 2026 thread tracking and following the roster developments. I try to update this at worst weekly, but during Free Agency I almost always will update it immediately as confirmation happens. In season tracking of signings (both PS and 53) will be tracked as well.

2026 Roster as of 1/20/2026

QB

Jordan Love
Desmond Ridder
Kyle McCord

RB
Josh Jacobs
Marshawn Lloyd
Pierre Strong
Damien Martinez
Chris Brooks - Re-signed
Emanuel Wilson *RFA


TE
Tucker Kraft
Luke Musgrave
Drake Dabney
McCallan Castles
Messiah Swinson


WR
Christian Watson
Jayden Reed
Dontayvion Wicks
Matthew Golden
Savion Williams
Bo Melton - Re-Signed
Jakobie Keeney-James
Will Sheppard
Isaiah Neyor
Skyy Moore - Signed UFA

OL

Dalton Cooper
Travis Glover
Anthony Belton
Zach Tom
Karsen Barnhart
Brant Banks
John Williams
Aaron Banks
Jacob Monk
Elgton Jenkins
Sean Rhyan - Re-signed
Darian Kinnard *RFA - tendered
Donovan Jennings *ERFA



DL/Edge
Devonte Wyatt
Warren Brinson
Karl Brooks
Nazir Stackhouse
James Ester
Anthony Campbell
Dante Barnett
Jordon Riley
Jaden Crumedy
Jonathan Ford *ERFA
Lukas Van Ness
Micah Parsons
Collin Oliver
Barryn Sorrell
Brenton Cox - Signed 1 Year
Colby Wooden traded
Rashan Gary traded

LB
Edgerrin Cooper
Isaiah McDuffie
Ty'Ron Hopper
Jamon Johnson
Zaire Franklin - Traded for from Colts
Nick Niemann - Re-signed
Kristian Welch - Re-signed

CB

Carrington Valentine
Keisean Nixon
Shemar Bartholomew
Benjamin St. Juste - Signed as UFA
Kamal Hadden *ERFA
Trevon Diggs released 1/20/26
Nate Hobbs Post June 1st release

S
Xavier McKinney
Evan Williams
Javon Bullard
Mark Perry
Tyron Herring
Johnathan Baldwin
Jaylin Simpson
Kitan Oladapo

ST
P - Daniel Whelan
K - Lucas Havrisik
K - Brandon McManus
LS - Matthew Orzech
K - Alex Hale *ERFA


UFAs 2026
Malik Willis
Romeo Doubs
Kingsley Enagbare
Rasheed Walker
Quay Walker
Zayne Anderson
John Fitzpatrick
 
Last edited:
Joined
Aug 16, 2014
Messages
20,433
Reaction score
10,353
Wonder how much they will offer?
My guess is in the 4yrX$48 ballpark or similar to Hobbs

My personal belief is he’s a closer to a $9mil year producer. Just imo. Like I’d offer him a 3yrX$25mil and inch it to $28mil then I’d bail out above that.
 
OP
OP
tynimiller

tynimiller

Cheesehead
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
18,600
Reaction score
8,289
My guess is in the 4yrX$48 ballpark or similar to Hobbs

My personal belief is he’s a closer to a $9mil year producer. Just imo. Like I’d offer him a 3yrX$25mil and inch it to $28mil then I’d bail out above that.

To be fair, most guys in the new wave of FA signings make about 20% more than what most think they're worth. It's the nature of escalating contracts. I do think a 4/48 or 4/50 is his top with 4/40 his likely lowest contract - and it isn't because I think he should be worth that, it simply is that he is in this league right now.
 
Joined
Aug 16, 2014
Messages
20,433
Reaction score
10,353
To be fair, most guys in the new wave of FA signings make about 20% more than what most think they're worth. It's the nature of escalating contracts. I do think a 4/48 or 4/50 is his top with 4/40 his likely lowest contract - and it isn't because I think he should be worth that, it simply is that he is in this league right now.
Oh yeah it always surprises me how these guys get paid. It’s whatever a team will do to land Quay if they think he’s an ideal fit. It’s just my opinion but once you sniff $10mil per year there’s lots of options at Off Ball LB. Heck I’m not sure he’d bail but Eric Wilson played fantastic last year. Really outplayed Quay Walker and he cost $2.6Mil.
 

melvin dangerr

In it to Win it All
Joined
Sep 9, 2012
Messages
4,917
Reaction score
1,723
Location
ST Croix VI
Sooo Pass on Al Harris for D coordinator, and hire the fired Cardinals coach, pass 3 seasons 15-36 record so why not have given AL a shot? Who knows could have brought some much needed toughness too the D. Imo
 
OP
OP
tynimiller

tynimiller

Cheesehead
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
18,600
Reaction score
8,289
Sooo Pass on Al Harris for D coordinator, and hire the fired Cardinals coach, pass 3 seasons 15-36 record so why not have given AL a shot? Who knows could have brought some much needed toughness too the D. Imo

Actually dig into what Gannon has done, especially in a **** situation like Arizona was.

This past season they had over $125+ million contracts on IR - it was the highest IR in the league.
 
Joined
Aug 16, 2014
Messages
20,433
Reaction score
10,353
Not really a fair comparison. Wilson will be 32 for the 2026 season. He's only getting 1 year deals from here on out.
The comparison wasn’t to show some long term 5 year roster strategy. The example was to show that you can build a Roster in a Win Now without blowing your entire checkbook.

Wilson is not the only FA Off ball linebacker in the league. If Q wants to get paid let him do it elsewhere. Past around $6-8Mil annual, I’d go after more pressing needs. We just drafted 2 LB’s in 2024-25 it’s time to test our drafting strategy. To replace them on Teams or as backups, there’s some really good LB’s RD4-7
 
Joined
Aug 16, 2014
Messages
20,433
Reaction score
10,353
Actually dig into what Gannon has done, especially in a **** situation like Arizona was.

This past season they had over $125+ million contracts on IR - it was the highest IR in the league.
Yeah I agree. I recall them and I believe SF49ersas the highest % of “impact” players out. Some others measure it in $$$.

As far as $$ lost to IR and to give some semblance of how Arizona faired compared to our own complaints about injury.
Arizona $142Mil
Green Bay $92mil

Here’s an article I read in week 13 showing The teams most impacted by injuries.



Arizona started 2-0. Then Until their Bye week in Week 8, across 5 losses their average points differential were -2.6 per loss. So just like our matchup with them they were very much in each game. At least until the injury list started climbing. By week 13 they were #2 most injured by impact player count. By close of season 1/2 of the roster was out.
 
Last edited:

mradtke66

Cheesehead
Joined
Feb 9, 2011
Messages
2,027
Reaction score
795
Location
Madison, WI
The comparison wasn’t to show some long term 5 year roster strategy. The example was to show that you can build a Roster in a Win Now without blowing your entire checkbook.

Even 10M wouldn't be blowing the pay check. Even 10M is just over 3% of the 2026 cap number. Not advocating much more than that, just level setting.

Wilson is not the only FA Off ball linebacker in the league. If Q wants to get paid let him do it elsewhere. Past around $6-8Mil annual, I’d go after more pressing needs.

Quay is a little special due to his measurables, which of course complicates things. He's probably top 5 there, but decidedly not top 5 in football intelligence. Having him out there helps cover up other stuff just by being fast. I struggle to put specific value on him due to the conflicting information.

We just drafted 2 LB’s in 2024-25 it’s time to test our drafting strategy.

The could also just not yet be up to the task. That Hooper is at best our number 4, maybe number 5 off the ball linebacker isn't a ringing endorsement.
 
Joined
Aug 16, 2014
Messages
20,433
Reaction score
10,353
Even 10M wouldn't be blowing the pay check. Even 10M is just over 3% of the 2026 cap number. Not advocating much more than that, just level setting.
that’s surely an optimistic view and I’m an optimist. It still doesn’t properly display how much $10mil a year is to what AVAILABLE cap.

I don’t care if we’ve got $2,000,000,000 Billion cap. If we are struggling to rearrange contracts to get out of negative for league thresholds allowed and in addition, trying to create $20mil to retain/resign 6-8 FA’s? $$10Mil is massive. Now maybe the contract is a little less or structured in a way it’s manageable at $5mil today, that’s why Russ gets paid the big $$
The could also just not yet be up to the task. That Hooper is at best our number 4, maybe number 5 off the ball linebacker isn't a ringing endorsement.
That could be said with temporary applause about virtually any player that was behind a pair of top 40 selections and an entrenched 5 year starter at LB. Especially on a team who makes you earn your way into starting lineup.
First example is Jordan Morgan but to say he’s no good because he’s not our starting LT etc. isn’t a proper way to analyze a player or even a proper representation of said player.
 
Last edited:

mradtke66

Cheesehead
Joined
Feb 9, 2011
Messages
2,027
Reaction score
795
Location
Madison, WI
that’s surely an optimistic view and I’m an optimist. It still doesn’t properly display how much $10mil a year is to what AVAILABLE cap.

I don’t care if we’ve got $2,000,000,000 Billion cap. If we are struggling to rearrange contracts to get out of negative for league thresholds allowed and in addition, trying to create $20mil to retain/resign 6-8 FA’s? $$10Mil is massive. Now maybe the contract is a little less or structured in a way it’s manageable at $5mil today, that’s why Russ gets paid the big $$

To me it's the incremental cost. Your range seems to be 7M-ish, you and I are maybe (as I said, I'm struggling to put my exact value on him. I'm throwing out 10M as it is a round number and isn't near the top) 3M apart. That's less huge.

Further, cutting Jenkins (all but assured before week 1 of 2025) and likely Gary frees 31M, give or take, in 2026.

As far as our own URFA, we only have 9. Exclude Diggs (probably not worth it), Willis (he's looking to be a starter), Doubs (I have to assume he's chasing a starting position and we have his likely replacement) and R. Walker (not that great and we have his replacement on the roster) we're down to 5.

The only three I'd actively look to keep are Quay (we don't really have his replacement on the roster), Rhyan (I actually like him, I know we disagree), and Enagbare (Gary's presumed departure creates a hole on the roster). SportTrac estimates their yearly averages at roughly 6, 7.5, and 8.2. Actual cap numbers are of course fuzzy depending on the structure.

That could be said with temporary applause about virtually any player that was behind a pair of top 40 selections and an entrenched 5 year starter at LB. Especially on a team who makes you earn your way into starting lineup.
First example is Jordan Morgan but to say he’s no good because he’s not our starting LT etc. isn’t a proper way to analyze a player or even a proper representation of said player.

It isn't fair, you're right. What is fair, to me, is who can't he beat out, does he get to play when injuries happen, and how does he play when given the chance.

To use Morgan as example, he's looked like he's worth at least trying him out based on how he's looked at tackle this year. No real reservations.

Hooper, I'm disappointed that he hasn't been able to overtake McDuffie--the man is smart as hell, but he's athletically limited. Maybe the pick against the Bears in the playoffs is the thing that pushes him forward, but again, I'd rather he push McDuffie down the depth chart.
 

melvin dangerr

In it to Win it All
Joined
Sep 9, 2012
Messages
4,917
Reaction score
1,723
Location
ST Croix VI
Actually dig into what Gannon has done, especially in a **** situation like Arizona was.

This past season they had over $125+ million contracts on IR - it was the highest IR in the league.
Your right Arizona was a mess but what do you think he will bring to GB to make the D better.
 

CarryTheG14

Cheesehead
Joined
Jan 26, 2026
Messages
84
Reaction score
57
Oh yeah it always surprises me how these guys get paid. It’s whatever a team will do to land Quay if they think he’s an ideal fit. It’s just my opinion but once you sniff $10mil per year there’s lots of options at Off Ball LB. Heck I’m not sure he’d bail but Eric Wilson played fantastic last year. Really outplayed Quay Walker and he cost $2.6Mil.
I like Quay. I'm not the biggest fan, but I do like him on this team.

I would be utterly shocked if he wasn't on the team next year. They love him. You can tell by how they talk about him. I think Quay adds to the team more than most fans realize (certainly me). Maybe Gannon doesn't see it that way though, who knows.
 
Joined
Aug 16, 2014
Messages
20,433
Reaction score
10,353
Thats good. He is the one free agent I don't think we can lose without seeing drop off.... We only have 4 LBs on the roster besides him too.
It’s about cost to me. He’s not worth anything past $8-10Mil annual. He is an above average LB, I’m just still on the fence with him. IMO he’s replaceable at less $$ than the likely $10Mil annual he’ll sign for. I’d almost prefer we part from his $10Mil and draft a LB by RD5 area. Similar to what we did there with McDuffie. I’d prefer we use $10Mil annual to get the best version of OC, DT or CB.

I do think GB will appease him an overpay. Which I understand they don’t have time to wait a year he’s plug n play. Which is with something there.

That said I do think GB will resign either Niemann or Welch, so they’ll have 4 LB’s on contract very soon. Just imo. So reestablishing Quay as a fixture would become 5 on contract. That does help alleviate 1 position to not have to focus on this draft. LB. We could wait until RD5-7 etc.

I see both sides on this Quay argument. Now if we locked him on a 3yr/$25Mil type deal and could only apply $5mil without much cap push? I’d be all over that. My fear is he gets a 3yr $35mil type contract and I just see better ways to apply that $$$
 
Last edited:

GreenBaySlacker

Cheesehead
Joined
Feb 5, 2014
Messages
3,745
Reaction score
525
It’s about cost to me. He’s not worth anything past $8-10Mil annual. He is an above average LB, I’m just still on the fence with him. IMO he’s replaceable at less $$ than the likely $10Mil annual he’ll sign for. I’d almost prefer we part from his $10Mil and draft a LB by RD5 area. Similar to what we did there with McDuffie. I’d prefer we use $10Mil annual to get the best version of OC, DT or CB.

I do think GB will appease him an overpay. Which I understand they don’t have time to wait a year he’s plug n play. Which is with something there.

That said I do think GB will resign either Niemann or Welch, so they’ll have 4 LB’s on contract very soon. Just imo. So reestablishing Quay as a fixture would become 5 on contract. That does help alleviate 1 position to not have to focus on this draft. LB. We could wait until RD5-7 etc.

I see both sides on this Quay argument. Now if we locked him on a 3yr/$25Mil type deal and could only apply $5mil without much cap push? I’d be all over that. My fear is he gets a 3yr $35mil type contract and I just see better ways to apply that $$$
I'm just remembering all those years GB spent looking for their star ILBs. Seemed like a never ending hemorrhage of high draft picks spent trying to fill those spots.... Walker and Cooper have been a solid duo for us. After dropping a 1st and 2nd of course.... We haven't heard much about need at their positions since their arrival

SEems like the middle ground is an even $10/yr.

I did like McDuffie when walker was hurt this year. Others aren't as high on him being a starter. But I seen solid tackling. Just have to question he he can keep that pace a full season....
 

CarryTheG14

Cheesehead
Joined
Jan 26, 2026
Messages
84
Reaction score
57
Someone said this on The Pack-A-Day podcast, and I think it's a great idea.

Trading Jaden Reed for either a premium day 2 pick(s) or a player.

I find it hard to believe they're going to re-sign him.

He's a purely slot guy who doesn't block.

Watson is their guy that will be extended again
Golden is a number 1 pick
Kraft will be extended
They drafted Savion.

GB has problem units. CB, DT, offensive and defensive lines. These are groups I don't want to rely on rookies. Trade Reed for a CB and cross it off the list.
 
OP
OP
tynimiller

tynimiller

Cheesehead
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
18,600
Reaction score
8,289
Someone said this on The Pack-A-Day podcast, and I think it's a great idea.

Trading Jaden Reed for either a premium day 2 pick(s) or a player.

I find it hard to believe they're going to re-sign him.

He's a purely slot guy who doesn't block.

Watson is their guy that will be extended again
Golden is a number 1 pick
Kraft will be extended
They drafted Savion.

GB has problem units. CB, DT, offensive and defensive lines. These are groups I don't want to rely on rookies. Trade Reed for a CB and cross it off the list.

Yeah, it's been a concept of internal discussions I can confirm and that is the future of Reed for sure. Drafting Golden and Savion, who both have massive overlap with their games to Reed drew stronger speculation on Reed's future than Doubs for me even.

In truth I think if we see it announced that Doubs and Green Bay came to a one year or even multi-year deal that it is shortly followed by the news that Reed is likely on the block or a trade deal was already in the works and will be executed. Now a foolish fan is going to hear this and read this and attack the concept or myself that we are idiots do you not understand Reed has been our leading receiver in yards twice and is a really good weapon....YES, this is all understood.

Sometimes roster decisions have to be looked at beyond the short sighted immediateness and from a what is best for the team overall. This team is firmly in a window to push for a Super Bowl, and yet given the high dollar contracts in place (Love, Parsons, Tom, McKinney) and few big ones to come (Kraft, Watson...Evan Williams...Wyatt)....trying to secure young guys to fill the depth and fill roles eventually on rookie deals is a massively important to sustaining that window as long as possible.

Trading a guy like Reed would suck...however even if say we don't sign Doubs as hinted at above...say he is gone. Wicks and Golden both are the clear candidates to fill that outside receiver role...but even slot work you have Golden, Savion and Bo Melton to a lesser degree ALL of whom have experience and shown promise. MLF used Savion and Golden in many of the same ways he used Reed when Reed was a weapon for us. Reed is also likely the guy with a contract ending that has the HIGHEST trade value with the least team impact...

Now I've heard folks say they think he'd get us a 2nd round pick....and maybe...but I think more likely is you nab a 3rd and like a 5th for him or maybe a clean 3rd but then swap a 4th for our 5th as well or something like that.
 

CarryTheG14

Cheesehead
Joined
Jan 26, 2026
Messages
84
Reaction score
57
Yeah, it's been a concept of internal discussions I can confirm and that is the future of Reed for sure. Drafting Golden and Savion, who both have massive overlap with their games to Reed drew stronger speculation on Reed's future than Doubs for me even.

In truth I think if we see it announced that Doubs and Green Bay came to a one year or even multi-year deal that it is shortly followed by the news that Reed is likely on the block or a trade deal was already in the works and will be executed. Now a foolish fan is going to hear this and read this and attack the concept or myself that we are idiots do you not understand Reed has been our leading receiver in yards twice and is a really good weapon....YES, this is all understood.

Sometimes roster decisions have to be looked at beyond the short sighted immediateness and from a what is best for the team overall. This team is firmly in a window to push for a Super Bowl, and yet given the high dollar contracts in place (Love, Parsons, Tom, McKinney) and few big ones to come (Kraft, Watson...Evan Williams...Wyatt)....trying to secure young guys to fill the depth and fill roles eventually on rookie deals is a massively important to sustaining that window as long as possible.

Trading a guy like Reed would suck...however even if say we don't sign Doubs as hinted at above...say he is gone. Wicks and Golden both are the clear candidates to fill that outside receiver role...but even slot work you have Golden, Savion and Bo Melton to a lesser degree ALL of whom have experience and shown promise. MLF used Savion and Golden in many of the same ways he used Reed when Reed was a weapon for us. Reed is also likely the guy with a contract ending that has the HIGHEST trade value with the least team impact...

Now I've heard folks say they think he'd get us a 2nd round pick....and maybe...but I think more likely is you nab a 3rd and like a 5th for him or maybe a clean 3rd but then swap a 4th for our 5th as well or something like that.
Do you know someone who works in the office or something?

It's easy to like Reed and see why it makes sense to move on for him. We have BIG contracts coming up.


As you said Kraft, Watson, Williams, Wyatt. But also Bull and Cooper. You can't pay everyone.

When you pay your QB premium money, you have to rely on him to make his pass catchers better. You do not want to end up like Cinci. Watson, Golden ( hopefully, but I am confident in him) and Kraft is a good core of pass catchers for Love. There shouldn't be any more significant assets being spent there.
 
OP
OP
tynimiller

tynimiller

Cheesehead
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
18,600
Reaction score
8,289
Do you know someone who works in the office or something?

It's easy to like Reed and see why it makes sense to move on for him. We have BIG contracts coming up.


As you said Kraft, Watson, Williams, Wyatt. But also Bull and Cooper. You can't pay everyone.

When you pay your QB premium money, you have to rely on him to make his pass catchers better. You do not want to end up like Cinci. Watson, Golden ( hopefully, but I am confident in him) and Kraft is a good core of pass catchers for Love. There shouldn't be any more significant assets being spent there.

I do have a few connections, however the statement comes more from my connections have always confirmed future plans are constantly mapped out and thought through. The construction of the wide receiver room is for sure one of those...and in truth the drafting of Golden and Savion to anyone that understands football and MLF system saw that as more of a potential replacement of Reed than it was a Doubs or Wicks type guy.

As for contracts I was in truth only speaking to guys with impending one year and gone....exception was Evan Williams who is like Bull and Cooper, but IMO has showcased incredible consistency and continues to progress into potentially being elite. I love Bull and Cooper but they're guys I'm likely not extending until that final year or off season.
 

Latest posts

Top