rank the packers

[ivo610]

how would you rank the packers starters?

 

[Green_Bay_Packers]

Mason Crosby- Amazing, Stunning, OMG!
100/100

 

[ShreveportCheesehead]

i dont like mason i think he over rated just because of his leg strength he misses too many chip shots 40's

 

[Green_Bay_Packers]

i dont like mason i think he over rated just because of his leg strength he misses too many chip shots 40's

BOO!

Boo!

 

[Future]

Can we get some specific guidelines? Rank them in order of best to worst? Assign them Madden-style ratings? Compare them against other players at their position across the league?

Sounds like a fun discussion.

 

[Big E]

Aaron Rodgers - 99 out of 100
Clay Matthews- 5 out of 5 stars
Charles Woodson - 2 thumbs up :thumbsup: :thumbsup:
Greg Jennings - A+
BJ Raji - Outstanding
Tramon Williams - "Like"

 

[ivo610]

Im sorry I should have given an example.

Here I go

1. Rodgers
2. Matthews
3. Williams
4. Jennings
5. Collins
6. Woodson
7. Raji
8. Finley
9. Clifton
10. Shields
11. Grant

Just an example. Go as far down the roster as you want but it gets reeeeeeal hard at about 10 I think.

 

[Jordyruns]

1)Rodgers
2)Matthews
3)Woodson
4)Raji
5)Williams
6)Jennings
7)Collins
8.) Sitton
9)Finley
10)Clifton
11)Nelson

Went back and forth between Raji and Williams a lot. I like Raji a lot and feel he is very underrated for what he does so had to go with BJ there.
I take it this is based on next season and i can't put Grant on the list until he shows he can do something after the injury.
After this it would probably be between Hawk, Bishop, and Grant.

 

[PackersRS]

It depends. Rank them by importance?

If so, Woodson is ahead of Tramon Williams.

But rank them by how good they are? Williams is better than Woodson right now.

Another example, I would rank Clifton ahead of Sitton based on importance, but Sitton ahead based on quality.

 

[Bensalama21]

To be honest, I think people are underrating Finley (Maybe because of the injuries) ... He brings a mismatch to every game and is almost unstoppable with Rodgers. Proven? No. Naturally gifted physically and pure talent? Yes.

1. Aaron Rodgers
2. Clay Matthews
3. Jermichael Finley
4. Greg Jennings
5. Josh Sitton
6. Charles Woodson
7. Tramon Williams
8. Nick Collins
9. Josh Sitton
10. B.J. Raji
11. Cullen Jenkins (If he remains on the team)
12. A.J. Hawk
13. Chad Clifton
14. Desmond Bishop
15. Ryan Grant
16. James Jones
17. Jordy Nelson
18. Scott Wells
19. Ryan Pickett
20. Bryan Bulaga
21. Sam Shields
22. Donald Driver
23. James Starks
24. Nick Barnett (If on team and would be higher if younger)
25. Daryn Colledge
26. Matt Flynn
27. Brandon Jackson
28. Morgan Burnett
29. Brandon Chillar
30. Mark Tauscher
31. Korey Hall
32. Mike Neal
33. John Kuhn
34. Erik Walden
35. Charlie Peprah
36. Tim Masthay
37. Jarrett Bush
38. Mason Crosby
39. Brad Jones
40. Andrew Quarless
41. T.J. Lang
42. Frank Zombo
43.Howard Green
44. Quinn Johnson
45. Jason Spitz
46. Atari Bigby (Probably Could be higher)
47. Tom Crabtree
48. Pat Lee
49. C. J. Wilson
50. Brett Swain
51. Spencer Havner
52. Jarius Wynn
53. Robert Francois
54. Graham Harrel
55. Brett Goode (Another role player that could be higher)
56. Nick McDonald
57. Brandon Underwood
58. Matt Wilhelm
59. Diryal Briggs
60. Evan Dietrich-Smith

Sorry if it's long!

 

[FrankRizzo]

To be honest, I think people are underrating Finley (Maybe because of the injuries) ... He brings a mismatch to every game and is almost unstoppable with Rodgers. Proven? No. Naturally gifted physically and pure talent? Yes.

1. Aaron Rodgers
2. Clay Matthews
3. Jermichael Finley
4. Greg Jennings
5. Josh Sitton
6. Charles Woodson
7. Tramon Williams
8. Nick Collins
9. Josh Sitton
10. B.J. Raji
11. Cullen Jenkins (If he remains on the team)
12. A.J. Hawk
13. Chad Clifton
14. Desmond Bishop
15. Ryan Grant
16. James Jones
17. Jordy Nelson
18. Scott Wells
19. Ryan Pickett
20. Bryan Bulaga
21. Sam Shields
22. Donald Driver
23. James Starks
24. Nick Barnett (If on team and would be higher if younger)
25. Daryn Colledge
26. Matt Flynn
27. Brandon Jackson
28. Morgan Burnett
29. Brandon Chillar
30. Mark Tauscher
31. Korey Hall
32. Mike Neal
33. John Kuhn
34. Erik Walden
35. Charlie Peprah
36. Tim Masthay
37. Jarrett Bush
38. Mason Crosby
39. Brad Jones
40. Andrew Quarless
41. T.J. Lang
42. Frank Zombo
43.Howard Green
44. Quinn Johnson
45. Jason Spitz
46. Atari Bigby (Probably Could be higher)
47. Tom Crabtree
48. Pat Lee
49. C. J. Wilson
50. Brett Swain
51. Spencer Havner
52. Jarius Wynn
53. Robert Francois
54. Graham Harrel
55. Brett Goode (Another role player that could be higher)
56. Nick McDonald
57. Brandon Underwood
58. Matt Wilhelm
59. Diryal Briggs
60. Evan Dietrich-Smith

Sorry if it's long!

Well done and I agree with Sitton at about 9, where you have him (although Raji is better).... but you also list Sitton at 5, and I suspect you meant someone else.

CJ Wilson is going to get a lot higher on that list in time......

 

[Murgen]

Overall I rank them "Pretty Damn Good" or PDG.

I think it's hard to compare positions. So I'll just say the top 10 (in no particular order) that jump to mind are.. Drum roll please.

Aaron "Mister" Rodgers
Clay "The Predator, hunt you down and put your skull in his collection of alien skulls in his spaceship" Matthews
Greg "Put the team on his back" Jennings
Jermichael "OMG, he's got stickum for hands" Finley
Charles "In Charge" Woodson
Tramon "Earning the money" Williams
Nick "To the house" Collins
Donald "Mr. Clutch" Driver
Raji "Like a G-6" Raji
A.J. "Playing like he means it" Hawk

 

[PackersRS]

Trying to take into account both importance and level of play, as of the immediate end of SB XLV, with every player healthy:

1st tier
Aaron Rodgers
Charles Woodson
Clay Matthews

2nd tier
Tramon Williams
Nick Collins
Greg Jennings
Josh Sitton

3rd tier
Chad Clifton
Desmond Bishop
Cullen Jenkins
B.J. Raji
Jermichael Finley
Scott Wells

4th tier
A.J. Hawk
Donald Driver
James Jones
Jordy Nelson
Sam Shields
Ryan Grant
James Starks
Nick Barnett

5th tier
Charlie Peprah
Ryan Pickett
Bryan Bulaga
Tim Masthay

6th tier
Daryn Colledge
John Kuhn
Mike Neal
Morgan Burnett
Mason Crosby
Mark Tauscher
Brandon Jackson
Brad Jonees
Frank Zombo
Eric Walden
Jarrett Bush (based on importance on ST!)
Matt Flynn

7th tier
C.J. Wilson
Atary Bigby
Howard Green
Brandon Chillar
Andrew Quarless
Tom Crabree
T.J. Lang

8th tier
Jarius Wynn
Pat Lee
Brett Swain
Johnny Jolly
Jason Spitz
Evan Dietrich-Smith
Brady Poppinga
Brett Goode

9th tier
Marshal Newhouse
Graham Harrell
Nick McDonald
Derrick Martin
And the rest that hasn't been mentioned already

 

[Wood Chipper]

sometimes its clearly obvious we are bored

 

[Bensalama21]

sometimes its clearly obvious we are bored

Haha true! and for my list just imagine Sitton at 9 not 5 and 9 both. Must have rushed it.