I'm sorry, but it's not as "clear-cut" and "black and white" as you would like it to be
SF Game:
Favre didn't exactly play "great" in that game overall ... - The winning drive ... was in fact "vintage" Favre ... - Not many other quarterbacks would have been able to "buy time" and get the ball down there as he did ... like him or not ... you'll have to admit that ... - I also wrote that Lewis did in fact make a GREAT catch, however, I also know that the pass *could* have gone incomplete (againt those "famous" marginals), but the "fact" remains ... only a very few quarterbacks in the league would have made that throw land where it did as well ...
In this game the play makers were Favre and Lewis ...
Pittsburg Game:
Again, Favre did play pretty well overall in that game (aside from the strip fumble) - The interception (from the throw to Chester Taylor) could have been played differently, but it didn't ... and resulted in a turn over for TD ...
In this game the play makers were the Steelers Defense (and the Minnesota Defense as well) ...
I just don't see it as "black and white" as you do ...
In fact I've been saying that all along ... - If you are going to "fault" players directly ... you should be consistent and not just "biased" ...