All right, smart ***. Here ya go.
OK, so lets look at a few QBR's since Eli was in the league. That was '04, right?
Eli's best rating was in '09 @ 93.1
Aaron Rodgers WORST rating was his first year as a starter in '08 @ 93.8 which is still better than Eli's best.
Peyton Manning in the same period had only one season worse than Eli's best and that was last year. 91.9
Except for 2005, it seems like Eli is just an average QB. Better than a lot. Not as good as some. Consistently mediocre.
Eli Manning
2011 - 92.9
2010 - 85.3
2009 - 93.1
2008 - 86.4
2007 - 73.9
2006 - 77.0
2005 - 55.4
2004 - 82.1
Aaron Rodgers
2011 - 122.5
2010 - 101.2
2009 - 103.2
2008 - 93.8
Peyton Manning
2010 - 91.9
2009 - 99.9
2008 - 95.0
2007 - 98.0
2006 - 101.0
2005 - 104.1
2004 - 121.1
Now, little boy...
BE GONE!
LOL, did u just drop QB Ratings as a sign of inconsistancy even though hes been in the same 7 point range?
Dude averages about 29 TDs and 4300 TDs a year. Thats pretty above average consistancy.
Not going to have the interceptions debate with u because you don't understand the offense, the drops, and im sure any point you could sugget I could apply to Drew Brees's interceptions.
Why don't you talk wins? Why don't you talk about the fact that the Giants have never had a losing record while Eli has been QB? Why don't you talk about the fact that he has the most 4th qtr comebacks out of anybody in the NFL (or second most, I forget)? Why don't you talk about the fact that WHEN we win this week Eli Manning will have the most road wins in the playoff? Do you not mention it because your such a fantasy football guy?
If stats toldthe whole story, you'd be sitting where we are this week and playing in the NFCC. Oh wait, i forgot you don't know if ur a Dallas, 49ers, or Pack fan. Well put it this way, after this week Eli will be knocking out ALL THREE OF YOUR TEAMS.
I suggest you keep your eye off the QB Ratings and stats to try and make your points. IF stats told the whole story then Kerry Collins would be regarded as one of the best QBs of all time and that Tony Romo would be elite.
Not to mention hes 6-3 in the playoffs with a ring.... welcome back to reality... son