Trade Rodgers, start Hundley

[Dblbogey]

Yes, I'm just kidding. Killing time waiting for the actual season, having delusional thoughts, kind of like Mike Sherman seemed to have regularly. Got me wondering what kind of return you could get on a hypothetical Rodgers trade, though.

 

[PackAttack12]

Sweet mother of the Lord.

 

[Candidate for Deletion]

Trade Rodgers, with the trade criteria that the team who gets him also has to take Dom Capers. I'd call it a wash.

*mic drop*

 

[C-Lee]

Godgers for Brock straight up.

 

[Pokerbrat2000]

Yes, I'm just kidding. Killing time waiting for the actual season, having delusional thoughts, kind of like Mike Sherman seemed to have regularly. Got me wondering what kind of return you could get on a hypothetical Rodgers trade, though.

Bad day to stop/start sniffing glue?

Possibly a one way ticket out of Green Bay, with no return and if you are lucky, your dog is alive when you leave (ok, GB Dan Devine Urban Myth).

You must be logged in to see this image or video!

 

[Mondio]

what would we get? not enough

 

[Sky King]

Realistically, a 1st rounder the year Arod turns 45.

 

[PackAttack12]

what would we get? not enough

Aaron Rodgers would be worth another team's 1st rounder for every single season that he played for that team. And it still wouldn't be enough.

 

[Pokerbrat2000]

Aaron Rodgers would be worth another team's 1st rounder for every single season that he played for that team. And it still wouldn't be enough.

Great, picking first (cause we would suck) and at the end of every round (Rodger new team would win)! More CB's!!

 

[Poppa San]

Before last draft, Cleveland had like 2 firsts and three seconds for 2 drafts. That sounds about right.

 

[HardRightEdge]

Got me wondering what kind of return you could get on a hypothetical Rodgers trade, though.

Three 1st. and two 2nd. round picks. Then hope you can get a franchise guy in the draft with one of those picks and wait a few years to get back into contention as he develops. In the mean time, use the cap savings to add some quality FAs to the defensive side hoping to stay competitive by keeping the scores down.

Sign Kaepernick to start for a year or two to hold us over.

What's the value of a true franchise QB? Priceless.

 

[HardRightEdge]

Sweet mother of the Lord.

Yeah, lots of intangibles, but can she read a defense?

 

[Curly Calhoun]

Yes, I'm just kidding. Killing time waiting for the actual season, having delusional thoughts, kind of like Mike Sherman seemed to have regularly. Got me wondering what kind of return you could get on a hypothetical Rodgers trade, though.

Or........Trade Rodgers and Hundley. Start Taysom Hill......:>)

 

[Dirty Sanchez]

dblbogey,
For that cute joke, I'm going to need you to do a little penance. I hereby require you to watch 3 Viking games and 2 Bear games! None of which can be against the Packers!
Go now and realize what you have said!

 

[Candidate for Deletion]

Or........Trade Rodgers and Hundley. Start Taysom Hill......:>)

What is with all this Taysom Hill love? Callahan > Hill any day. Hill can back up Callahan, who can throw to Clark, Mcaffery, Allison, Dupree, Yancey, and Crockett - after we also trade Nelson, Adams, and Cobb. I think we should be able to net 7-8 1st rounders with a slew of 2nd-5ths and some extra lates thrown in.

 

[NJPackfan..]

Only a Vikings fan would suggest the Packers trade Rodgers

 

[Candidate for Deletion]

Only a Vikings fan would suggest the Packers trade Rodgers

Only a Bears fan would fail to see the humor?

 

[Dirty Sanchez]

Wow! Those are fight'in words where I come from!

 

[Curly Calhoun]

What is with all this Taysom Hill love? Callahan > Hill any day. Hill can back up Callahan, who can throw to Clark, Mcaffery, Allison, Dupree, Yancey, and Crockett - after we also trade Nelson, Adams, and Cobb. I think we should be able to net 7-8 1st rounders with a slew of 2nd-5ths and some extra lates thrown in.

I was being facetious, in spirit of the thread.

As for Hill, is athletic ability is intriguing, and I think may find his way to the practice squad. I'm not quite ready to anoint him as Canton-bound yet however.

 

[Candidate for Deletion]

I was being facetious, in spirit of the thread.

As for Hill, is athletic ability is intriguing, and I think may find his way to the practice squad. I'm not quite ready to anoint him as Canton-bound yet however.

I didn't think you were that serious lol (though there has been a legitimately disproportionate amount of Hill love around these parts - I think it's just because the 3rd vs 4th qb matter about as much as the water boy, and we all like shiny new toys)

 

[Pokerbrat2000]

I think its pretty obvious that either Hill or Callahan will be our #3 and the other guy most likely will not be a Packer, no need to carry 4 QB's on the roster and PS. I also hope that whoever it is, we are able to stash him on the PS and not use a roster spot. Maybe cut both and sign whoever is not picked up or the best one if they both are still available?

These next 2 games (especially the final one) will determine who that guy is and possibly, who our #2 QB is when Hundley is out of GB. I like Callahan, but there is something that intrigues me about Hill and his athleticism. I don't think Hill being 25 is a negative, it actually might even be a positive. However, his injury history as well as being in the Packer system for only 1 camp, might be his downfall.

The move that would surprise a lot of people is either Hill or Callahan really show something special in the next 2 games and the Packers find a trade partner for Hundley and one of them becomes our #2. I don't see that happening, Hundley right now is much better than either of them and having him for insurance is far more valuable than a future draft pick. Now if the trade was for a player that could instantly benefit the Packers AND Hill or Callahan show they could be a #2.......then it would get interesting.

 

[El Guapo]

I loved Callahan last preseason. However, this is where you have to show it and Hill has outplayed Callahan in both games so far. Hundley shows the poise and patience that a true starter needs in the NFL. Hill and Callahan are gamers who might succeed with all of the right pieces in place for them.

Moving Rodgers in a Hershel Walker type of trade would rock the NFL, and we wouldn't be able to sneak through the under-the-surface conditional draft picks that made that deal great, but we could have one heck of a bounty. There are teams out there that would do the deal.

You must be logged in to see this image or video!

 

[Wi. Mike now in Florida]

Imagine if this was suggested years back to trade Brett Farve and keep Arron Rogers.............

 

[El Guapo]

I'm still of the strong belief that Rodgers wouldn't be as great as he is, had he not sat for years behind Favre - learning what to and what not to do.

 

[VegasPacker]

Knowing that we probably still have about 8 more years of Rodgers, I would say no amount of compensation would be nearly enough.