ThePerfectBeard
Cheesehead
I'm probably in a minority, but I'd rather have McCaffrey than Cook.
I'd rather have Mixon over both to be honest. However, that's based on talent alone because I'm not going to argue about what he did. It definitely wasn't right, but he wouldn't be the first player in the NFL to do something disgusting at a young age and he won't be the last. Remember, Tyreek Hill beat his pregnant girlfriend, but the Chiefs' fans seem to have forgiven him because of his play.
Mixon seems remorseful and teams had the time to interview him if they are concerned. However, based on talent alone, the kid is a stud and is absolutely the best fit for our team.
Cook disappointed at the combine and already has fumbling problems. I also don't believe McCaffrey is going to hold up for a full season if he has to run it up the gut. And let's face it, Fournette is definitely not falling out of the top 10.
Over all, Mixon has the perfect skill set with great hands, quick feet, vision, and the ability to run with power when needed. He's very similar to Le'Veon Bell and I couldn't imagine what this offense would be like if we had someone comparable to Bell.