Hi guys I was wondering if you guys could think of any packers (Pre Favre era) you would consider great players that no one ever talks about? Trying to put something together for the forum at some point and bringing back old names would help. I know we have some members on here that know all about the "old school" players.
Forgotten Packers
- Thread starter ivo610
- Start date
AllouezPackerFan
Section 121 Row 47
Lynn ****ey obviously. Zeke Bratkowski is a name that never gets mentioned, Cecil Isbell and Tobin Rote were EXCELLENT Packer quarterbacks.
At running back, John Brockington, Donny Anderson, Vince Workman, Keith Woodside, and Brent Fullwood.
Jeff Query was one my favorite players when I was growing up. I also loved Chuck Cecil.
At running back, John Brockington, Donny Anderson, Vince Workman, Keith Woodside, and Brent Fullwood.
Jeff Query was one my favorite players when I was growing up. I also loved Chuck Cecil.
AllouezPackerFan
Section 121 Row 47
Obviously you can go wayyyyy back and talk about guys like Cal Hubbard, Cub Buck, Arnie Herber, Johnny "Blood" McNally, Clarke Hinkle, Tony Canadeo, and even Curly Lambeau. My grandpa always loved talking about Arnie Herber because he was a Green Bay native and went to West High School.
I can still hear him, "Arnie Herber...Green Bay native, could throw the ball 60 yards with pin point accuracy."
I can still hear him, "Arnie Herber...Green Bay native, could throw the ball 60 yards with pin point accuracy."
OldSchoolFan
Cheesehead
Dave Robinson, Jerry Kramer and Dan Currie all belong in the Pro Football Hall of fame. Everyone knows Willie Davis, but few can mention Bob Skoronski, and he was the offensive captain for years under Lombardi. Go ahead and google Henry Jordan, Lionel Aldridge, Ron Kostelnik and Lee Roy Caffey and read about how their lives ended waaaay too soon. Gale Gillingham is an interesting read too, crazy how his career came to an end.
Well, going back I dunno how GOOD they were (I was a kid) but they stick in my head.
Tim Harris
Don Majikowski
Lynn ****ey, saw a game\ played against the SB champ Redskins and man, he was tearing them up!!!
James Lofton
Tim Harris
Don Majikowski
Lynn ****ey, saw a game\ played against the SB champ Redskins and man, he was tearing them up!!!
James Lofton
neilfii
Hall of Fame Fan
Willie Wood, Herb Adderley, Carroll Dale, Travis Williams, and although Nitschke gets some love I don't think he gets enough.
Ed "toolbox" West, Ken Ruettgers, Mike McCoy (DL, played OL in a pinch and got his leg broken), Chester Marcol, Larry McCarren
Helmets
Cheesehead
Willie Buchanan, Ken Bowman, **** Himes, and Charles Martin for slamming McMahon...
DevilDon
Inclement Weather Fan
- Joined
- Jan 10, 2010
- Messages
- 1,393
- Reaction score
- 268
Chuck Cecil was the James Harrison of his day, just a wrecking ball. Lynn ****ey was a scream to watch with Sterling. Ed West and Paul Caufman were great pass catching TEs. Tim Harris was really great for a bit. The first Packer sack master that I remember. Oh, and Bryce Paup was great to watch for a bit.
Brian Noble
Eddie Lee Ivory
Bryce Paup
Eddie Lee Ivory
Bryce Paup
Helmets
Cheesehead
Psst...
****ey retired following the '85 season. Sterling Sharpe joined the NFL as a rookie in 1988...
Helmets
Cheesehead
Willie Wood, Doug Hart.
I met and shot with Doug Hart at a sporting clays tournament in Florida a few years back. At lunch we argued as to if he was the one that broke Devine's leg. He claimed it wasn't him, but watching that game as a know it all seven year old, I remembered it differently.
I met and shot with Doug Hart at a sporting clays tournament in Florida a few years back. At lunch we argued as to if he was the one that broke Devine's leg. He claimed it wasn't him, but watching that game as a know it all seven year old, I remembered it differently.
OldSchoolFan
Cheesehead
That was the defensive end known as Ezra Johnson.
His motto- "Why be a hotdog when you can eat them?"
He liked his with pickle relish and lots of mustard....ketchup gave him gas....
Johnson gobbled up QBs . . . hot dog - JSOnline
Thought it was Brent on sidelines of a Bear game when Forrest was HC?
GreenBayGal
Cheese Goddess
Didn't Michael Jackson & Paul McCartney do a song about him? (think ******* this one)
ebony and ivory 
OldSchoolFan
Cheesehead
"GreenBayGal will be here all week...now be sure to take care of those hard working bartenders..."
totalpackers
Cheesehead
Just wrote an article for the Packers Hall of Fame site -- Packers not in the Pro Football Hall of Fame that should be. Without going into all the reasons why, which are many, here is the list.
Not all pre-Favre, but I'd be happy to put any of them up for debate with the greatest of all time.
Lavvie Dilweg
Bobby Dillon
Billy Howton
Jerry Kramer
Dave Robinson
Sterling Sharpe
LeRoy Butler
Not all pre-Favre, but I'd be happy to put any of them up for debate with the greatest of all time.
Lavvie Dilweg
Bobby Dillon
Billy Howton
Jerry Kramer
Dave Robinson
Sterling Sharpe
LeRoy Butler
Wow Butler isnt in??
GreenBayGal
Cheese Goddess
I don't think Leroy is fogotten in Wisconsin.
Welcome to the Official LeRoy Butler Foundation! (he also has a Ford dealership in Waupaca, WI)
Welcome to the Official LeRoy Butler Foundation! (he also has a Ford dealership in Waupaca, WI)
AllouezPackerFan
Section 121 Row 47
I honestly feel like Cecil Isbell and Tobin Rote are two of the most overlooked Packers in team history. Both were EXCEPTIONAL quarterbacks.
weeds
Fiber deprived old guy.
It's hard to make a case for this guy being 'forgotten' given his stature and the accolades he's received over the years...but his is still the jersey I came closest to buying...as I've said, I've NEVER owned a jersey with a player's name on it. Now, I wasn't a kid when he played...I was in my late teens/early 20's, I have a vivid recollection of the guy who ran like a gazelle (and also had a rep for dropping an easy one every now and again) and essentially rewrote the Packers' record book. On top of that, the guy was a gentleman's gentleman - and I really believe he got a bum deal in lilly-white Green Bay of the 70's and 80's - like it or not, times were a whole lot different than they are now 30 years ago...and when all is said and done...well... you know.... anyway, I'd have to say James Lofton. I really wish that he would have finished up in Green Bay, but hey...he got to his Super Bowl with Buffalo...so... you know... I'm happy for him.
Similar threads
