The Good:
-Christian Watson is not just fast, he's explosively fast. Meaning that he has both acceleration and speed. MVS, who many people have comp'd Watson to, had a 1.55 ten yard split at the combine, which is very good. Watson had a 1.46, which is 97th% regardless of size, and he's 6'4" 208. So yes, he's fast, but we aren't talking about the traditional long-striding build up speed kind of guy. This is real "get on top of you" speed.
-Watson comes from an offense that does not play finesse players, period. I've seen more of the NDSU Bison crushing other teams than I care to and their identity is in running the ball and physically imposing their will. LaFleur doesn't want guys in this offense who won't block. Watson is going to be more than comfortable with that.
-At the Senior Bowl, Watson demonstrated a lot more ability as a route runner and press coverage beater than he was ever asked to demonstrate for the Bison. NDSU had him on a linear route tree against guys who just couldn't hang with him. He demonstrated that there's more to him than that.
The Bad:
-Watson is 23 years old. So he didn't just play against a lower level of opponent, he did it as an older guy, though to be fair he started really dominating at that level in his age 20 season.
-Watson had one of the highest drop rates in college football. Part of that might just be low sample size. NDSU is a low volume passing attack (Watson led the team with 43 catches and the next highest total on the team was 20). Furthermore, his depth of target was crazy high, so that's going to lead to more drops. But it's still higher than you want to see.
-The competition that Watson faced at the Sr. Bowl, while certainly better than they standard fare in the FCS, was not amazing. And we have seen guys look great in that context and then turn back into a pumpkin (Denzel Mims).
Conclusion:
Watson was not at the top of my list, but the tools were undeniable throughout the process. And I did not anticipate how quickly the vertical threats at WR would come off the board. I thought Pierce would be there for them if they stayed put, or Thornton later on. Thornton went #50 and the Colts took Pierce at #53. Pickens was off the board at #52, and one could easily imagine the Colts jumping Green Bay to pick Pierce earlier had the Packers stayed home. So given how it unfolded, I understand why the Packers wanted this particular player and why they moved up so aggressively to get him.
I think his floor is the MVS role in the offense, meaning a 35-40 reception vertical threat who keeps defenses from condensing towards the LOS. His ceiling is a lot higher than that; we will see what the coaching staff can do with him.