yet you are talking about how many passing yards eli would have had if not for dropped passes... Pot? Meet Kettle
for the record the packers were lucky to make the playoffs in 2010. I think a tampa game helped us, and then that D jackson return was a classic as well. Both were a big part of us making the playoffs that year.
You realize that is the point I am making? It is sarcasm highlighting that would of, could of and should of are irelevant. I neither have an idea nor do I care if Eli Manning would have led NFL in passing yards if not for dropped passes. If the passes were caught the game could have went another way and it would not have matterred. It is irrelevant.
Your argument is ridiculous. What it proves is that on that day and towards the end of the season the Giants were the superior team, and that for a lot of reasons. None of us have any way of knowing what would have happened if the Packers had brought their "A" game. They didn't, and I for one am not making excuses. The better team on that day won. On that point you are right. But to talk about the Giants as the "superior team" as if there's no other team out there that can touch them, that's silly. All you are saying is that since we won the Super Bowl, we're the superior team. Sorry. What it means is that since you won the superbowl, you're the league champions and you own the crown for a year. That you are/were superior to the Packers, Saints, 49ers or Patriots is what they call in them halls of academia, speculation, or what most the rest of us call, homerism.
No hard feelings against the Giants for what happened so I can't whole-heartedly say I'd like to see them flop .. with that being said, the Eagles in sheer regard to the amount of game they talk contrary to the amount of playoff games they have won in the last few seasons.
Green Bay Packers did bring their A game against NY Giants in poatseason and it just wasn't good enough. No hard feelings. Maybe you guys can field a team that will play better in the playoffs next time.
There's a reason why the giants aren't considered the best team right now and there is a reason Eli isn't considered elite. Hopefully it won't take you long to figure out why.
Folks tend to underestimate us over and over again. That ia quite alright with us. Go ahead and keep teeling yourself that Eli Manning is not ELIte and keep telling yourself NY Giants got lucky whatever makes you feel better. I will be content in watching Eli Manning continue with his career as he brings more Lombardi trophies for NY Giants.
What it proves is that NY Giants are World Champions and The Best in NFL till another team proves otherwise.
When is that? When they go 9-7? They miss the playoffs? The first loss of the season? The playoff loss? What a team does in feb doesn't entitle them to anything in sept.
The whole "Eli" in elite just makes me laugh. Sooo clever, I mean did you come up with that yourself?
Actually what NY Giants did in February entitled us for the 1st game of season on national television. It also entitles us to The Title "Reigning SuperBowl Champion NY Giants." Who do you think is best in NFL and why?
Nice debate we have going here with the Giants fan as long as we keep it civil!!! Both sides are making some good points. I am always up for watching the Cowboys tank! I love to watch them shoot themselves in the foot. The only other team I would enjoy seeing tank more is the Jets but that's a given with me.
True. Enjoy it now while it lasts. You won't get fumbles left & right next playoff season, if you make it into the playoffs.
You are OBVIOUSLY a dillusional homer. If you had seen the Packers play any other time during the year, there was no way that was even close to their A game.
I did see them play numerous games and the one against NY Giants in regular season left me very confident that when healthy we will beat them and we did.
we hung 38 on you in new jersey. No way we played with our A game in the playoffs. You seem very insecure about your team and how it's viewed. You keep saying we played our A game. But we both know that's not the case. Either way history says you won, so why do you care so much? Worried what will happen when we play up to par? When Rodgers throws 4 TDs? When Eli gets picked?
