The whole argument that Rodgers has better weapons is crap. Last season, Rodgers had the worst O-line in the league. Still had a probowl year. 7 INTS. Had good weapons, so that helped. You could argue that Rodgers had a running game and a quality TE to help out in tough spots last season. Okay, that's fine. Fast forward to this season. Rodgers loses Grant in the 1st quarter of the first game. Loses Finley 3 weeks later. So he's had ZERO running game this season, and no TE. STILL put's up solid numbers. Cutler has had a great running game with Forte this year and has a good TE in Olson. O-lines are on par with each other, neither one is anything to write home about. Rodgers numbers have just been better than Cutlers. Not sure what else to say.
Cutler is still the more physically talented QB. But it's more than just physical talent. Look at Manning.