One of the biggest reasons the Packers lost in the playoffs was because of defense. You are just not going to win a Superbowl with the worst ranked D in the league and I don't care if it's just on paper. We also should give the Giants their due from last season, they had one hell of a year and one that mirrored our season from the previous year. So congrats, Giants fan on your Superbowl. Now with that being said, it's a whole new year with a whole new set of circumstances. Arguing over who won the Superbowl last year or even the year before is not going to matter this year. Clean slate. If Eli can play consistently and the Giants continue to have a defense they will be a good team. Do you know how hard it is to win back to back championships? The Giants are going to have competition from the Eagles within their own division so if I were them I would be looking closer to home instead of worried about the Packers. If you are comparing Aaron to Eli, you will lose that battle on the basis of stats alone. They both have a ring but Aaron Rodgers blew Eli off the planet last year even though it was Eli who got the SB win. Again, new year. Refocus, clean slate.