Replace a Player with a Player

[DevilDon]

Jeff Saturday with Scott Wells.

 

[bozz_2006]

Jeff Saturday with Scott Wells.

You must be logged in to see this image or video!

You must be logged in to see this image or video!

 

[DevilDon]

You must be logged in to see this image or video!

You must be logged in to see this image or video!

Sure I do. Solid center with a future versus a stopgap. I'm not enamoured with Scott Wells but it would be nice to have a center with the correct butt height on the roster to learn before you release a guy.

 

[60six]

Sure I do. Solid center with a future versus a stopgap. I'm not enamoured with Scott Wells but it would be nice to have a center with the correct butt height on the roster to learn before you release a guy.

He over priced himself.

Had his best year as a pro.....yes you guessed it.....in his contract year.

 

[13 Times Champs]

Mike Neal with Cullen Jenkins.

 

[Bensalama21]

AJ Hawk (sadly) is our best ILB, what ILB would you replace him with?

Bishop is by far the best inside linebacker... He even was almost a pro bowler and led the team in tackles.

 

[GreenBlood]

DeMarcus Ware for Perry, Walden, Zombo and So'oto

(How can the Cowboys refuse that package?)

Why would you trade Agent P before you even know what we have in him?

 

[DevilDon]

He over priced himself.

Had his best year as a pro.....yes you guessed it.....in his contract year.

Overpriced himself says who? He got his money. He also had his best year after he had the most experience in the league in his career. Seems to make sense.

 

[ivo610]

Why would you trade Agent P before you even know what we have in him?

I would be shocked if he is an all decade player. Ware is just an animal. I like Clay, but Ware is as good and maybe even better.

 

[60six]

Overpriced himself says who? He got his money. He also had his best year after he had the most experience in the league in his career. Seems to make sense.

IMO he's an average football player, and the Rams overpaid.

 

[HyponGrey]

a player like Pierre-Paul could easily adapt. Talent is talent.

I have my doubts. Talent is talent, but there are other factors. He'd need to put on some girth and learn how to 2-gap, or learn to play coverage and move to linebacker. And trust me when I say weight and speed are hard to balance.

How about Hawk for Willis, Peprah for Goldson, Saine for MJD or Rice, Quarless for Gates, Harrell for Brady (ride the pine, Tommy, ride the pine), (Herb) Taylor for Clady, or EDS for Mack or Watkins

 

[ivo610]

I have my doubts. Talent is talent, but there are other factors. He'd need to put on some girth and learn how to 2-gap, or learn to play coverage and move to linebacker. And trust me when I say weight and speed are hard to balance.

How about Hawk for Willis, Peprah for Goldson, Saine for MJD or Rice, Quarless for Gates, Harrell for Brady (ride the pine, Tommy, ride the pine), (Herb) Taylor for Clady, or EDS for Mack or Watkins

Has to be the best player at the position according to the first post. I would start with the Harrell argument if you think he is the best QB on the roster.

 

[HyponGrey]

Has to be the best player at the position according to the first post. I would start with the Harrell argument if you think he is the best QB on the roster.

I did in fact miss that, disregard previous post.

 

[ChicagoPackerBacker]

Matt Forte for James Starks.