Caleb or Jordan for the win

[El Guapo]

At this point of the season, if your team is down with one minute left in the game, do you want Caleb Williams or Jordan Love for the win?

 

[BrokenArrow]

Is Willis an option?

 

[Magooch]

Allow me to hedge a little bit. If my choices are exactly as they are (same teams, staff, etc) right now then I might lean Williams. He is awful for long stretches but has a rare flip-the-switch ability when it’s crunch time…it’s close though. At bare minimum I think Love is good enough to get it done in that kind of situation.

But if situations were swapped and it’s Love playing for Chicago (players, staff) vs Williams playing for GB then I’d go with Love

 

[Snoops]

I would say the story of the bears season comes down to 4th qtr comebacks…. That’s the answer right there… Love struggles at playing from behind. Love has what done it one time against the saints…? Only thing I think about is how love burnt almost 30 seconds in Dallas getting to the line of scrimmage and lucky they got a tie….
Hope that answers your question lol

 

[Thirteen Below]

That’s the answer right there… Love struggles at playing from behind. Love has what done it one time against the saints…?

From what I can see, he has 4 4th quarter comebacks this season, and would have 5 if not for the blocked field goal in Cleveland.

 

[tynimiller]

Love at this point in their careers.

 

[gopkrs]

Love

 

[OldSchool101]

I would say the story of the bears season comes down to 4th qtr comebacks…. That’s the answer right there… Love struggles at playing from behind. Love has what done it one time against the saints…? Only thing I think about is how love burnt almost 30 seconds in Dallas getting to the line of scrimmage and lucky they got a tie….
Hope that answers your question lol

@Snoops Jordan has 8 combined 4Q comebacks (4) and GW drives (4) in 2025. Beating his previous record of 5 total (2023). His 4 GWD were Arizona, Pittsburgh, Giants, Chicago

In totality
Caleb has 7 Game Winning Drives but 6 of them came in 2025 alone which is crazy good. Speculative SOS
He’s 34 Starts (20.6%)
Caleb had 70.6% of his games either 4QC (6) or GWD (6) this year alone.

Jordan has 9 Game Winning Drives across 48 Starts (18.8%)

Pat Mahomes is Yoda of GWD.
34.9% of his Starts either 4Q comebacks or Game winning drives.
13 combined 4Q comebacks and Game Winning Drives across 23 playoff games (61.9%)!

I’ll take Pat Mahomes. With 1 leg!

 

[OldSchool101]

I think I’d have to give the 4Q comeback nod to Caleb, but it’s a slight nod due to more recent examples and due to the array of high echelon players around Caleb. Caleb has 1+ (or more) GWD in every month so far except January.