QB Rankings - Pro Football Focus 2009

[FrankRizzo]

ProFootballFocus.com - By Position

AGOD.
But a Rivers Runs Through It?

 

[PackersRS]

Lie I said in another thread, they say they rank each and every play, but they don't say HOW they attribute points to each action...

Truth be told, Rivers was amazing last year...

 

[ivo610]

when talking just passing Rodgers falls to 6th which is interesting, and sadly you know who jumps up to #1. As great as Arod was last season I think he will only get better in the next two yrs.

 

[Wolvi]

His combination of passing and ability to run really put him in a different level!

 

[ivo610]

His combination of passing and ability to run really put him in a different level!

Yeah but off the top of my head only 1 running QB has ever won a SB. I might be forgetting someone though...

 

[FrankRizzo]

Yeah but off the top of my head only 1 running QB has ever won a SB. I might be forgetting someone though...

Elway and Young were both once great runners, great athletes.

 

[PackersRS]

Elway and Young were both once great runners, great athletes.

Favre was too, let's not forget.

But yeah, Rodgers eerie similar to Steve Young...

 

[ivo610]

Elway and Young were both once great runners, great athletes.

Elway won SBs at about 38 yrs old and at that point he was far from a great runner. I know everyone remembers the helicopter play but he was slow as hell and even he admits that.

 

[ivo610]

Favre was too, let's not forget.

But yeah, Rodgers eerie similar to Steve Young...

Favre was great at maneuvering around the pocket but was not a runner like vick, young, or fran.

 

[barehead]

i saw another thread talk about this

 

[PackersRS]

Favre was great at maneuvering around the pocket but was not a runner like vick, young, or fran.

But Rodgers isn't either IMHO...

For starters, Vick is a RB that can pass. He's not a QB.
Young and Tarkenton, they were certainly scramblers. But Young used it in a last resource manner. I think Tarkenton was more propense to run with it...