In a lot of the running situations, if the Chi D was left to guessing, they got it right. And by the look on MM's face, he didn't always seem pleased with the results of the play. I agree that Starks may have been dancing a bit but that's probably because he had nowhere to go. Blame it on the O-line, the play call, or their D...it wasn't working.
I wouldn't say I'm "dissapointed" in MM, just not sure I understand some of his logic. But then again, he's the head coach of a world championship team and alas, I am not.
What would you say your results should be when guessing? 50/50? I think you're about right on that. What kind of look were you seeing on MM's face? Do you mean he wasn't smiling when they didn't get a first down? I must not be watching the game earnestly enough, I don't remember alot of cues from his face. In fact, I don't pay much attention to the coaches face during the broadcast, I might be missing something.
But lets keep in mind that passes in obvious passing downs are risky plays, alot of things can go wrong, the pass can be tipped and intercepted, the QB can get creamed on an all out blitz and the pass can fall incomplete which nets you absolutely 0 yards.
Last, doing unorthodox things in the game may not even help in that game, but it will make other teams who are looking at tape of your previous games wonder. I'd rather see MM keep drilling it down their throats like you, but I can see where he might want to play it this way.
And yes, it's not all on James Starks. Anybody who has read my posts for awhile here can tell you that I'm really, really high on Starks' future and have been long before the playoffs last year. You're absolutely right, he didn't have alot of room, but when he did he was indecisive, I know you saw it like I did. I think it was just one of those things, Grant had the holes this game. I'm not worried one bit about Starks' long term look.