- Joined
- Jun 6, 2005
- Messages
- 2,207
- Reaction score
- 0
then how about Antonio Freeman?
Does he belong in the Packer Hall of Fame?
Does he belong in the Packer Hall of Fame?
PackerTraxx said:Sharper and Freeman have numbers enough to go into the PHOF, but it is not a slam dunk.
Yes he made some nice plays in bad seasons but then again at that time so did Corey Bradford and Billy Schreador.
Injury played a MAJOR part in Majik's fall from the Number One QB position.. hands down!musccy said:Prez...I'm not being critical of Majik at all, I'm just saying that he had a few really strong years, and then was more or less done (yes injury played a part)..
agopackgo4 said:Are you serious?!?!?????????????????? Freeman?? He had like two good years for the pack that is it! Yes he made some nice plays in bad seasons but then again at that time so did Corey Bradford and Billy Schreador.
Obi1 said:Chase,
Are you REALLY comparing the two? You've GOT to be kidding. Freeman was no where NEAR the receiver SS was.
I know, I know, Packers should re-sign Freeman... Right?
musccy said:traxx...this sharper thing is basically what Drew Rosenhaus' biggest beef w/ the NFL is...Both sides agree to a deal, but if the team thinks you're underperforming, you're cut...but if the player thinks he's outplaying his contract, tough luck.
Now of course I understand why that is, I'm all against the Javon thing, blah blah, and of course Sharper had to have known he was stealing from the Pack...but if I were Sharper, would I be a little upset that contracts weren't 2-way streets, maybe a little bit.
Actually, I think SW is right - part of what is taken into consideration rght off - is the Player's performance stats. We didn't win any SuperBowls with Sterling Sharpe on the Roster, either! In fact, I'll go so far as to say Sharpe was an ego-maniac who thought the whole team revolved around him. Whereas Freeman was just overpaid and decided to do what we now call the Randy Moss syndrome (I play when I wanna play).Obi1 said:Chase,
Are you REALLY comparing the two? You've GOT to be kidding.
Freeman was no where NEAR the receiver SS was....