Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="PackersRS" data-source="post: 273140" data-attributes="member: 1429">Not one play. A lost at a Superbowl, added to a series of early quits in the playoffs.Whoever considers Marino as the best ever needs a serious lobotomy, nothing personal.Hypothesis that will never be tested cannot enter in the subject. Fact is fact, and fact is Marino couldn't win it all, and that Manning didn't win it. Brees did. He playes his mind out, with a lot of people were saying was inferior talent.You just can't consider a guy the best ever if he never won a SB in 10+ years. Not when guys like Montana, Starr and Graham won so much, while playing lights out.It's not greatness that's being contested. It's all around superiority.Marion is the best regular season QB ever. Manning could surpass him. Favre is for sure a top 5.But the mark of a great qb is postseason sucess and clutchness. Starr has the best postseason ratings of ALL TIME, and has 5 championships, 2 SB rings, and 2 SB MVP rings. Montana has 4 SBs and 3 SB MVPs. Manning and Marino don't come even close to that.</blockquote>

Total: 1,560 (members: 3, guests: 1,557)