Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Beebe82" data-source="post: 640052" data-attributes="member: 9778">The rest of your post was about how we shouldn't judge Edgar Bennett because we don't know his exact role. I agree. Lets be hypothetical. McCarthy up until this year spent 90-95 percent of his time with the offense and 5 to 10% with the defense. Up until 2015 aside from maybe 2006 the offense has been potent. 2015 comes around and McCarthy changes his role, he now spends 30 to 40% of his time with the offense and 60 to 70 percent of his time with the defense. Now, the  defense is much improved over 2014 and the offense regresses significantly. My assertion is, McCarthy is a great teacher and coach and needs to be intimately involved with both sides of the ball and all units because his other coaches aren't nearly as talented as he is. Now in the real world you and I will never know what percentage of time McCarthy spends with all units, but let's assume his reason for giving up play calling duties was to spend more time with the defense because McCarthy didn't feel the talent was living up to its potential.Tl:dr McCarthy is a great football coach and a less than average evaluator of coaching talent which limits the success of the Packers.</blockquote>

Total: 265 (members: 4, guests: 261)