I say no.
Talented, yes, but the odds of him being loud, obnoxious, demanding the ball, and showing up our young QB are high.
Give me Donald Lee and our 2nd round rookie.
tromadz said:I say no.
Talented, yes, but the odds of him being loud, obnoxious, demanding the ball, and showing up our young QB are high.
Give me Donald Lee and our 2nd round rookie.
Usually Trom I almost always agree with you. In this case we will have to agree to disagree. For what most likely ends up being a 2nd, I say get him. It's not a Madden move, albeit a slight gamble. Sometimes a guy just needs a change, plus in GB he would be the man - something I think would be good for The Rod.
tromadz said:I say no.
Talented, yes, but the odds of him being loud, obnoxious, demanding the ball, and showing up our young QB are high.
Give me Donald Lee and our 2nd round rookie.
Usually Trom I almost always agree with you. In this case we will have to agree to disagree. For what most likely ends up being a 2nd, I say get him. It's not a Madden move, albeit a slight gamble. Sometimes a guy just needs a change, plus in GB he would be the man - something I think would be good for The Rod.
Had our QB been Favre this year I would be all for this. Rodgers doesn't have the status of being looked up to that Favre garnered over the years.
The reason why I'm not a big fan of Jeremy Shockey is because in the locker room he doesn't know his role. He thinks he's the leader of the team but in reality he should just shut up and play football. The Giants success started when he got hurt. Why? Not because Shockey was off the football field but Eli Manning was allowed to become the leader.
This brings me to the current Green Bay Packers.
If Brett Favre was still around I could see Jeremy Shockey playing for the Packers. Even he would know his role in the offense and have to shut up for Favre. Favre has earned that.
Aaron Rodgers hasn't. So if the Packers brought Shockey in I think he'd probably be the same guy he was in New York and it might hurt Rodgers more than help him in some ways. For that reason alone I really don't know if it's worth giving a 2nd (I think a 2nd is what they'd take) for Shockey. The Packers might be better off acquiring someone else.
The Giants were sucking hind end till Shockey got hurt.
After he was out for the season they started their improbable run for the Super Bowl.
Coincidence?