Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Sanguine camper" data-source="post: 835166" data-attributes="member: 9744"><p>I voted for Hudson. He was a man among boys when you look at his highlight clips and dominant stats. Second place would be Rodgers. He makes plays no other qb in the nfl has ever made. Just rewatch that crazy throw to Janis in the playoffs vs Arizona. Third and fourth would be Gregg and Adderly. They were premier players who dominated their position for years in the league. Lombardi called Gregg the greatest player he ever coached. Deferring to Vince's judgement makes sense to me. Fifth would be Nitschke and sixth Reggie White. If Reggie had played his entire career in Green Bay, I'd rank him higher but he was only a Packer for 6 years. Farve could be awesome one game and then stink up the next one. He was the Babe Ruth of interceptions and choked too many times in the playoffs to be ranked in the top ten. Starr was tough as nails and clutch! I think he benefited from being on such a great team so I would rank him as number seven. Lofton was a great player on bad teams and put up incredible numbers for the time. I would put him at 8. Had Woodson played longer, he might be rated higher like Reggie but talk about a playmaker! No other Packer on defense routinely made so many game changing plays. No. 9 imho. Finally, don't forget about Sterling Sharpe. His 6 seasons were dominant and he was on his way to a first ballot hof career.</p></blockquote><p></p>

Total: 223 (members: 3, guests: 220)