Have at it:
1) Peyton Manning - His stats are amazing and he still has multiple years on a potent offense to get that elusive ring. His defense could still hold him back however.
2) Tom Brady - Hard to argue with 3 Rings, but aye, there's the rub: How much of that was the staunch Patriots Defense and BB? Its a nice story about how he was a 6th rounder but its not enough to get him to #2.
3) Donovan McNabb - A perfect blend of running ability and passing ability. His stats are somewhat inflated due to the one dimensional Offense of the Eagles but his touch and accuracy get him to #3. One of the best deep balls today.
4) Carson Palmer - A little early for my taste to be putting him so high so soon but his numbers and this throwing accuracy are elite. His knee injury worries some, including me, but until it proves to hamper him or delay his starting here he is.
5) Daunte Culpepper - Didnt expect this one did ya? As much as I hate Daunte his passing numbers are undeniable. He has troubles with the mental aspect of the game and he is careless with how he holds the ball when he drops back, but he is still an elite QB.
6) Matt Hasselback - A steady 3500 passer with 20+ TDs every year, his amazing performance this year boosted his ranking to me. He is everything you could want in a QB, not much to argue with here.
7) Eli Manning - A rocky start to the league today but he shows undeniable talent and skill and he soon could be knocking on the Top 5. Look for him to put up big numbers on a potent Giants Offense.
Jake Delhomme - See Matt Hasselback.
9) Byron Leftwich - A little high, yes, but if he can work out some minor issues with his game then he could be elite. Dont forget that the Jags lead the league in drops this year.
10) Michael Vick - His stats arent all that amazing and he goes to Pro-Bowls he shouldnt but his value to the Falcons is undeniable. He is an amazing player with physcial talent that is second to none in QBs today. Contrary to popular belief he is not the first of his kind: Cunningham and Tarkenton.
11) Ben Roethlisberger - Im sorry but throwing the fewest passes of anyone on this list, getting into a mortorcycle accident, without a helmet and saying watching film is "overrated' doesnt get you in the Top 10.
12) Brett Favre - As much as it pains me, he is an undeniable Top 10 QB of all time. Last season was injury plagued and he took risks. He isnt 1/2 as good as he could be with a better mental game but he is that good. Age might restrict him in the upcoming year however.
13) Trent Green - Age is the only factor in preventing him from being higher, he is a constant 4000+ passer and one of the more underrated QBs of the modern era.
14) Drew Brees - Benefited like McNabb from a capable RB but he is a steady passer who will add stability to a rocky Saints team.
15) Marc Bulger - Its debatable between him and Plummer. He could suffer without Martz.
-----------
1) LaDainian Tomlinson | San Diego Chargers
2) Tiki Barber | New York Giants
3) Clinton Portis | Washington Redskins
4) Shaun Alexander | Seattle Seahawks
5) Larry Johnson | Kansas City Chiefs
6) Rudi Johnson | Cincinati Bengals
7) Edgerrin James | Arizona Cardinals
Deuce McAllister | New Orleans Saints
9) Jamal Lewis | Baltimore Ravens
10) Ronnie Brown | Miami Dolphins
11) Carnell Williams | Tampa Bay Buccaneers
12) Warrick Dunn | Atlanta Falcons
13) Thomas Jones | Chicago Bears
14) Fred Taylor | Jacksonville Jaguars
15) Steven Jackson | St. Louis Rams
***Note: If there is someone who you think should be on this list, but isnt please keep in mind that he is #16
1) Peyton Manning - His stats are amazing and he still has multiple years on a potent offense to get that elusive ring. His defense could still hold him back however.
2) Tom Brady - Hard to argue with 3 Rings, but aye, there's the rub: How much of that was the staunch Patriots Defense and BB? Its a nice story about how he was a 6th rounder but its not enough to get him to #2.
3) Donovan McNabb - A perfect blend of running ability and passing ability. His stats are somewhat inflated due to the one dimensional Offense of the Eagles but his touch and accuracy get him to #3. One of the best deep balls today.
4) Carson Palmer - A little early for my taste to be putting him so high so soon but his numbers and this throwing accuracy are elite. His knee injury worries some, including me, but until it proves to hamper him or delay his starting here he is.
5) Daunte Culpepper - Didnt expect this one did ya? As much as I hate Daunte his passing numbers are undeniable. He has troubles with the mental aspect of the game and he is careless with how he holds the ball when he drops back, but he is still an elite QB.
6) Matt Hasselback - A steady 3500 passer with 20+ TDs every year, his amazing performance this year boosted his ranking to me. He is everything you could want in a QB, not much to argue with here.
7) Eli Manning - A rocky start to the league today but he shows undeniable talent and skill and he soon could be knocking on the Top 5. Look for him to put up big numbers on a potent Giants Offense.
Jake Delhomme - See Matt Hasselback.
9) Byron Leftwich - A little high, yes, but if he can work out some minor issues with his game then he could be elite. Dont forget that the Jags lead the league in drops this year.
10) Michael Vick - His stats arent all that amazing and he goes to Pro-Bowls he shouldnt but his value to the Falcons is undeniable. He is an amazing player with physcial talent that is second to none in QBs today. Contrary to popular belief he is not the first of his kind: Cunningham and Tarkenton.
11) Ben Roethlisberger - Im sorry but throwing the fewest passes of anyone on this list, getting into a mortorcycle accident, without a helmet and saying watching film is "overrated' doesnt get you in the Top 10.
12) Brett Favre - As much as it pains me, he is an undeniable Top 10 QB of all time. Last season was injury plagued and he took risks. He isnt 1/2 as good as he could be with a better mental game but he is that good. Age might restrict him in the upcoming year however.
13) Trent Green - Age is the only factor in preventing him from being higher, he is a constant 4000+ passer and one of the more underrated QBs of the modern era.
14) Drew Brees - Benefited like McNabb from a capable RB but he is a steady passer who will add stability to a rocky Saints team.
15) Marc Bulger - Its debatable between him and Plummer. He could suffer without Martz.
-----------
1) LaDainian Tomlinson | San Diego Chargers
2) Tiki Barber | New York Giants
3) Clinton Portis | Washington Redskins
4) Shaun Alexander | Seattle Seahawks
5) Larry Johnson | Kansas City Chiefs
6) Rudi Johnson | Cincinati Bengals
7) Edgerrin James | Arizona Cardinals
Deuce McAllister | New Orleans Saints
9) Jamal Lewis | Baltimore Ravens
10) Ronnie Brown | Miami Dolphins
11) Carnell Williams | Tampa Bay Buccaneers
12) Warrick Dunn | Atlanta Falcons
13) Thomas Jones | Chicago Bears
14) Fred Taylor | Jacksonville Jaguars
15) Steven Jackson | St. Louis Rams
***Note: If there is someone who you think should be on this list, but isnt please keep in mind that he is #16
