Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="AmishMafia" data-source="post: 779915" data-attributes="member: 2846">Soooooo, Aaron Rodgers doesn't make the list? How good is the list?Player success is based on talent as well as coaching. Personally, I think coaching is far more important, and I think Belichick is the poster boy for that. Year after year his teams excell with different players. And most of his FA losses fail with their new teams.No. It is not obvious.The most talented team in the NFL in 1958 was the GBP with an incredible 7 future HOFers. Yet they won only a single game that year. Coaching is important!You equate a lack of success simply to no talent. I disagree with that. I see a lot of talent on defense. I see aggressive play and very good individual skills. I see the Packers play good for a bunch of plays and even series or two. Then I see a WR run free and DBs looking at each other confused. I have seen defensive gameplans that left me scratching my head. I see defensive players pointing fingers and disgruntled. I see players look good as rookies and then seem to fade and not develop. These are all coaching issues. The first valid statement you have made.  However I do like MM and can see why TT kept him.  MM should have pushed Capers to the curb 4 seasons ago and TT should have pushed for it.</blockquote>

Total: 559 (members: 1, guests: 558)