Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Jules" data-source="post: 420884" data-attributes="member: 4098">Neither can I. No need to apologize. I thought he was overrated even with the Colts although I would certainly take him over Caldwell. Dungy thought Favre should have won the MVP in 2009 btw. He said it a few times. And don't take this the wrong way but IMO Peyton SHOULD have carved up the Saints D like a surgeon. There was no excuse for that performance by the Colts offense IMO with the way they could run the ball finally in that game and with the weapons they had on offense. They had to carry a banged up D and they didn't. Two weeks before they carved up a much better Jets D at home and the week before that they handled the Ravens D. Both teams should have carved up each others D's. BTW don't listen to the media much. I hardly even turn on ESPN anymore. Before the Colts/Saints SB I knew they were almost setting up the Colts to fail. Many might have picked the Colts but they were rooting against them outside of Indiana. It was the Colts vs. everyone rooting for the Saints in many ways. I wanted the Vikings so the Colts did not have to go against such a feel good story. And The Who was the halftime show. The Who.....Who dat. It never sat completely right with me. It was almost like destiny for NO that year. One last thing I don't think Peyton won the MVP JUST BECAUSE his last name is Manning. I think thats a tad direspectful. It's not like he was mediocre that season. You guys can say what you want but he did not just win the award due to his name. Eli might benefit from the Manning name but Peyton certainly has proven himself time and time again. I still don't get why this 2009 MVP thing is such a big deal all of a sudden. I knew all year Peyton would win it when the media was calling our demise with Dungy/Harrison leaving in the offseason and we started 14-0. I never even realized it meant that much to Saints fans until I started to post here. Go figure. Although overall I am being honest when I say I might prefer Rodgers' game to Peyton or any other QB around right now. I think Rodgers is that good and he has a certain element of swagger too that I like. One thing missing from Manning despite his greatness was the fight of having to get to where you are. In some ways this season I have decided I want the Colts to move on and rebuild around Andrew Luck and try to build a complete team again and not just be a one man show.</blockquote>

Verification

Members online

No members online now.

Total: 378 (members: 0, guests: 378)

Latest posts

M
Christian Watson signs a 4 year 110m extension
- Latest: Magooch
- 55 minutes ago
Green Bay Packers Fan Forum
Badgers Football 2025-2026
- Latest: Voyageur
- Today at 2:15 PM
Wisconsin Badgers Forum
Movies and TV shows Thread
- Latest: Voyageur
- Today at 1:29 PM
Movies and Entertainment
Why I Love The 2026-2027 Green Bay Packers
- Latest: CarryTheG14
- Today at 11:42 AM
Green Bay Packers Fan Forum
2026 Roster Thread - Semi-Live
- Latest: Pokerbrat2000
- Today at 9:48 AM
Green Bay Packers Fan Forum