Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="adambr2" data-source="post: 1011833" data-attributes="member: 7277">"Good drafting is about retention"?So you're treating players as equals here as long as they are still in the NFL?  By this GM measuring stick, we're assigning the same level of success to the draft selections of Josiah Deguara and Royce Newman as we are to Amon Ra St Brown and Alim McNeill?In addition to that, some front offices are more apt to exercise patience with their fringe roster guys, whereas some front offices are more prone to just cutting their losses and moving on, which is further problematic for this grading scale. I'm sorry, but this is such a broad measurement of GM performance which misses out on so many details that you might as well just throw it out completely and come up with a different grading system.You cannot name one single "impact" player that Gute has drafted since the 2019 season. Not one. An actual, current impact player, not just "the potential to be one."The last was Gary, and he took a long time to get there. Since then, it's been a barren wasteland. You are not going to be competitive in the NFL with "guys that are good enough to be on a 53 man roster." The Josiah Deguara's and AJ Dillon's of the world are a dime a dozen and could be replaced tomorrow with no noticeable effects.</blockquote>

Total: 212 (members: 1, guests: 211)