Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="HardRightEdge" data-source="post: 550661">Not me.  There's a quip from an NFL personnel man that I'm fond of quoting:  when you have an elite QB you start at 8-8 and work up from there.  Conversely, when you're a team like the Bills playing with their 5th. QB since the start of training camp (or the Packers for that matter with guys like Wallace or Tolzien), you start at 8-8 and work down from there.Protestations to the contrary, a thoughtful analysis would show the only position group where the Packers have a clear advantage over the Bills is at QB.I'd give the Packers an edge at WR, but the Bills group would look a lot better with a guy who could throw the ball.  I'd say it's a wash at TE and RB and I'd give the Packers a slight advantage on the O-Line.  On the other hand, I'd give the Bills the clear edge in the D-Line and safety groups, and even an edge in the LB groups, Matthews notwithstanding.  The Pack gets a small edge at the CB position.I would trade our entire defense lock, stock and barrel for the Bills even with the loss of Byrd.</blockquote>

Total: 417 (members: 5, guests: 412)