Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="morningwood" data-source="post: 374713" data-attributes="member: 2110">I don't know how you could exclude Rodgers.  The only distinction is that he hasn't done as long, but that cuts both ways as he has gotten to the top fast.    Do I think Brees is better?  Well yeah, but I realize I am biased.   The distinctions between these top guys is not worth arguing over, IMO. I think Steve Young had the best take on this (thugh he wasn't talking about Rodgers at the time -- 09 game NO vs NE).   Young's point was that these guys are playing at such a high level that they have the position down to an art, and you really can't say one artist is "better" than the other.  Each is best for his team. Fortunately for you guys Rodgers is so young.  If you were selecting one QB for a team his youth would probably make the difference.  (Although I would still say screw it, I am taking Brees).</blockquote>

Total: 84 (members: 2, guests: 82)