Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Sunshinepacker" data-source="post: 525405" data-attributes="member: 9033">Our injured players are on the current roster. The question posed was if this team could win 5 games over an entire season. This being a hypothetical I chose this to mean a completely new season (since this season has already begun and therefore can't be used for the question). In a hypothetical season, this current roster would not have the exact same injuries. Just a different way of interpreting it. Yes, in a hypothetical season in which 5-8 of your best players in addition to Rodgers were injured, we would struggle to win 5 games. So would any other team in the NFL. There isn't a team that could withstand that level of injuries. If we insist on using our current injuries along with the Rodgers injury to speculate on wins, then the question is pointless. ANY TEAM would struggle to five wins with as many players injured as the Packers have had. Take Wilson, Harvin, any two of Seattle's terrible oline, Sherman, Earl Thomas, Bruce Irvin and Walter Thurmond off the Seattle roster and they will also struggle to five wins.</blockquote>

Total: 104 (members: 3, guests: 101)