Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Ace" data-source="post: 542556" data-attributes="member: 9774">When discussing GOAT as far as QB's go, the team around him has to be accounted for.  If it's based solely off of how many rings they win during their career well then Terry Bradshaw is in the conversation for GOAT.  I'm not putting him there but just using him as an example.  Can RW put his team on his back in the clutch and win a game?  The truth of the matter is, we don't know because he's never had to.  Maybe he can maybe he can't. I personally believe he can't and that will come to fruition once the incredible nucleus that Seattle has built begins to fall apart as it most certainly will in the next few years.  I think he is a very good qb, but he's also been blessed to be in the perfect situation for someone of his ability.  He isn't asked to win games, I mean he had 165 less pass attempts this year then Carson Palmer (10th overall) and 252 less then Manning, and Manning still was 5% pts better in comp %.  He's asked to not turn the ball over and manage the offense big difference then guys like Aaron who more often then not have to be perfect in order to win.</blockquote>

Total: 189 (members: 1, guests: 188)