IMO the answer to this question is the answer to a lot of questions like this: It depends. Of course that is not an exciting or bold answer but it’s the right one IMO: If there’s a PK later in the draft that would likely not be available as an UDFA and there’s not a position player they have graded in a talent tier above where they’re selecting, then yes they should draft him. Failing that I agree with the others: Bring in a UDFA and/or someone whose been trying to make it in the league as a PK. No matter what they should bring in some competition. And I know they like Crosby, but I hope they’ll allow a real challenge to his job.