Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="OldSchool101" data-source="post: 1037975" data-attributes="member: 10086">Greg Joseph is close to Crosby. Like 1% difference on FG career.However Crosby was slightly more consistent by a couple % on XPMI also liked that Crosby kicked more of his outdoors. Joseph is a C+ B- and would suffice.I really don’t think there would be much issue with him he’s a safer bet short term.  Greg is also a perfect 2/2 FG and  12/12 XPM in Postseason. Those are all XPM after the distance back adjustment some years ago.Greg doesn’t flinch when the game gets big. As far as Carlson. I do question Carlsons confidence a little and XPA should be near automatic at a 93% + area made. Carlson was under 90% XPM and under 80% FG made in postseason. 87% should be FG% not a XPM% etc. Thats a concern when a team is in Win now mode and those are thresholds that should be cause for concern if we get 4-5 games in and they aren’t met (again)I have no problem whatsoever with Carlson for a few games to see where he’s at. I also have no problem putting Joseph on PS in the wings.IMO I value a guy that is automatic inside 45 and can hit inside 55 yards in a pinch over a guy that has potential of a 60+ yarder etc.  Both are great but if I had to choose give me the better K inside 45</blockquote>

Total: 987 (members: 1, guests: 986)