Only problem I have with this list is #2 and #3. I would put Bart Starr at 2 and Favre at 6 or 7.No surprise Favre isn't number one, I figured Hutson had it, just reading about what the guy has done is crazy.
Surprising to see James Lofton so high... I guess the books I've read about the Packers have never talked about him as highly as the 60's guys. I agree with Don Hutson being #1, though, what that guy did in that era was incredible. We'll never be able to understand quite how big of an impact he had on the game. Favre obviously is overrated, but that's a dead horse.