Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="ivo610" data-source="post: 417881" data-attributes="member: 2128">You're right, I should do that.  I apologize. I am personally not a fan of limiting it to 1980, as do you count only what you have seen or their whole career if they played in 1980? I figure just include all QBs.  anyways heres who I would consider adding if we are only talking post 1980 Kurt WarnerJim KellyKen AndersonTerry Bradshawtroy Aikman  Warner and Bradshaw are the two I would most likely swap out for Brees and Fouts. For the record I am one of the biggest Favre haters around, no one here will argue that, but I personally disagree with you using stats as reasoning for the players above Favre.  would like to see some criteria for what makes the best QBs.  the first issue I see is Fouts above favre, with fouts being touted for his career yardage, even though favre has a ring and 30,000 more yards than him. Rodgers is #3, okay fair enough that is your opinion but when you do that you are comparing someone who is reaching the peak of his career to someone who is done with his career (favre).  As of today Favre has the same titles, been to more SBs and crushes Rodgers as far as career stats go.  Career wise Favre is head and shoulders above Rodgers. I love these lists though and appreciate seeing other peoples opinions, thank you for posting this, I am sorry I came across in a negative manner.</blockquote>

Total: 226 (members: 2, guests: 224)