PFF Best and Worst vs Viqueens Week 12 2025

[tynimiller]

As always 10 snap minimums needed to make list here:

Best Offense
Christian Watson - 82.5 (folks he truly was "torching" them without getting the ball...made me sad)
Luke Musgrave - 74.9
Emanuel Wilson - 72.2
Chris Brooks - 71.5
Zach Tom - 69.2

Worst Offense (when three of your bottom five are clear in the 50s...that is usually a good game)
Jordan Morgan - 38.9
Anthony Belton - 44.8
Darian Kinnard - 54.1
Sean Rhyan - 56.3
Malik Heath - 57.6

Best Defense
Isaiah McDuffie - 86.4
Xavier McKinney - 75.9
Micah Parsons - 71.7
Edgerrin Cooper - 70.5
Javon Bullard - 68.7

Worst Defense
Devonte Wyatt - 44.1
Carrington Valentine - 56.7
Keisean Nixon - 57.8
Colby Wooden - 58.6
Kamal Hadden - 62.3

 

[Firethorn1001]

Best Offense
Luke Musgrave - 74.9

You must be logged in to see this image or video!

 

[tynimiller]

You must be logged in to see this image or video!

It's because he started blocking like he did in College. I know folks love to attack him, and he for sure has underdelivered BUT if he embraces whatever mentality he brought against the Vikings, the kid will still be a valuable piece this year for the Packers with Kraft out.

 

[OldSchool101]

It's because he started blocking like he did in College. I know folks love to attack him, and he for sure has underdelivered BUT if he embraces whatever mentality he brought against the Vikings, the kid will still be a valuable piece this year for the Packers with Kraft out.

Sten said recently they are experimenting with various avenues in the wake of losing Kraft. Not just with the TE group, but that would be an ideal source to get production.

I don’t think it’s a surprise for any of us that Musgrave's best bet to get on that field? is to block his tail off when called upon.

 

[tynimiller]

I think truthfully one of the things is Musgrave wants to be that WR Jimmy Graham type TE so badly...but it isn't what this offense asked even Tucker to be AND it isn't what he excelled at in college either. Crossroads chance for him truthfully right now.

 

[Magooch]

Christian Watson - 82.5 (folks he truly was "torching" them without getting the ball...made me sad)

Not even trying to be flippant, I for real pray this guy can just stay healthy for a long time. Both for him personally and the team, I know it is brutal to keep having all those setbacks or "new" things cropping up. He is such a game changer for us when he's out there. Great player and even when he's not super "directly" involved he changes the defense approach big time.

Luke Musgrave - 74.9

That's gotta be one of the biggest one-week turnarounds you'll ever see, lol.

Emanuel Wilson - 72.2

Just for a little point of comparison, by my count we have seen Josh Jacobs in the "top 5" for 5 performances this year.
Bengals, 83.6
Cowboys, 81.8
Panthers, 81.2
Browns, 73.4
Cardinals, 71.2

Worst Offense
Jordan Morgan - 38.9

Alarms are officially sounding for me here...

Best Defense
Isaiah McDuffie - 86.4

He had a great game. Would be curious to see how they rated his coverage snaps, I know that's often been a low point

Micah Parsons - 71.7

This one surprised me. Given some of the crazy-high scores we've seen from him this season, and how much of an overt impact he appeared to have in this game, I would've expected much higher (I feel like in weeks past he has graded higher but "looked" to have done less. This week he appeared to do more and got graded lower)

Edgerrin Cooper - 70.5

Glad to see Coop back up here. I haven't checked too closely but feel like he's not been sighted in these lists a ton this season...

Worst Defense
Kamal Hadden - 62.3

IMO, speaks pretty positively overall when you have Hadden getting his first real reps and he's still grading in the 60s and that's amongst the worst on the defense. Not a bad day at all

 

[tynimiller]

He had a great game. Would be curious to see how they rated his coverage snaps, I know that's often been a low point

This one surprised me. Given some of the crazy-high scores we've seen from him this season, and how much of an overt impact he appeared to have in this game, I would've expected much higher (I feel like in weeks past he has graded higher but "looked" to have done less. This week he appeared to do more and got graded lower)

I can bring some light to these two...

McDuffie again usually suffers in coverage purely from a physical limitation, but every now and then he gets the right match up and continues to excel in knowing his role, responsibilities and he actually gets there...this game his coverage grade was solid at 88.2 (the highest of any player for us)

Parsons struggled this game against the run...but to be fair it wasn't bad at all just one or two misplays, but his worst grade this game was tackling.

 

[mradtke66]

Alarms are officially sounding for me here...

I still beat the drum that he's not a guard. He's fine in pass protection even there, but in the run game, he's not what you want.