PFF Best and Worst For 2025 Seasons

[tynimiller]

Welp...typically limit 10 snaps for game best/worst but for season just gonna eliminate outlier low snap guys overall...and threw in more than 5 depending on cluster of grades:

Best Offense
Jordan Love - 88.8
Josh Jacobs - 86.1
Zach Tom - 83.5
Christian Watson - 82.7
Tucker Kraft - 78.1
Romeo Doubs - 74.6
Matthew Golden - 70.5
Dontayvion Wicks - 70.2
Jayden Reed - 70.2

Worst Offense
Anthony Belton - 48.2 (rough start but ended well IMO)
Josh Whyle - 54.2
Luke Musgrave - 54.3
Aaron Banks - 55.6
John FitzPatrick - 56.3
Sean Rhyan - 59.2

Best Defense
Micah Parsons - 92.0
Xavier McKinney - 78.6
Edgerrin Cooper - 75.8
Lukas Van Ness - 75.7
Evan Williams - 71.1
Rashan Gary - 68.9

Worst Defense
Nazir Stackhouse - 44.1
Warren Brinson - 44.2
Quay Walker - 46.0
Karl Brooks - 46.3
Colby Wooden - 50.6

 

[DABIGZ]

IMO based on this we have the talent, especially on the offensive side. Defensive side though I'm a tad surprised. For how much we put Hafley on a pedestal the drop off from this year to last year is concerning.

 

[milani]

IMO based on this we have the talent, especially on the offensive side. Defensive side though I'm a tad surprised. For how much we put Hafley on a pedestal the drop off from this year to last year is concerning.

In part because we beat the Lions twice and smothered the Vikings once. Those were teams in the last few years who put up plenty of points against us. Not this year.

 

[El Guapo]

IMO based on this we have the talent, especially on the offensive side. Defensive side though I'm a tad surprised. For how much we put Hafley on a pedestal the drop off from this year to last year is concerning.

I still think that Hafley did one heck of a job with what he had. We came into the season knowing that we had a really weak secondary, but lost Slaton & Clark. Then we added Parsons but lost both him and Wyatt. Our defense did well in the first half of games but wore down in the second halves. A lot of that actually goes on the OL - who consistently failed to open holes in the running game and/or commit penalties, leading to many second half 3&outs. Our defense was continually fatigued with inferior players at key positions.

In part because we beat the Lions twice and smothered the Vikings once. Those were teams in the last few years who put up plenty of points against us. Not this year.

...and we mainly beat those teams because they were worse than last year. We played elite football in Week 1 but the Lions were not up to the task, as compared to last year.

 

[Zartan]

Im surprised Nixon wasnt listed on the worst defense.

 

[tynimiller]

Im surprised Nixon wasnt listed on the worst defense.

67.1

 

[Poppa San]

67.1

Basically in or near the top 10?

 

[tynimiller]

Basically in or near the top 10?

Yup and very hot or cold in games it seems - better than I thought he’d do