Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Half Empty" data-source="post: 639777" data-attributes="member: 10288">So, would it be a stretch to say you're talking about the eye test and personal evaluation?  If we watch the same TV screen, are we going to agree that ____ is better at his job than the other guy, and that he performs the function his position requires - is that the same for everyone, or are we now talking a 'system' QB?  Raw talent to do what - again, same for all?  What 'more' - would like to hear about additional criteria?Is there some measure that would sway a football-knowledgeable but neutral observer?Also, there is, I think, a reasonable argument to be made for asking if we're talking about great QBs, great passers, or if they're the same thing.Obviously, of course, none of this will every get settled, but at least there needs to be a straw-man for the discussion.</blockquote>

Total: 57 (members: 2, guests: 55)