Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Magilla" data-source="post: 451483" data-attributes="member: 6744">Tom Brady hardly collapsed in SuperBowl XLVI. Wes Welker makes that catch and it is highly likely they win the game. However the flio side of that argument is if Mario Manningham had made the catch on the previous drive then NY Giants may have been able to put that game away. Claiming that Tom Brady collapsed in SuperBowl XLVI is a ridiculous statement. He brought NE Patriots back when he orchestrated perhaps 2 of the greatest drives in SuperBowl history when he broke rhe consecutive completion record. NE had taken control of thay game but Eli Manning and NY Giants offense slowed it down and controled the clock keeping Tom Brady on the bench. TOP was 38 minutes for NY and 22 for NE.Bart Starr may be the greatest playoff QB so far but to say that he is head and shoulders above Tom Brady makes absolutely no sense. Brady has done way more with less. Lets not forget that Starr won gis Championships always having the number one or number two defense in NFL.Okay if the poll were taken after the post season Rodger may have broken the top 5 but there is no way he even sniffs number one in that scenario.</blockquote>

Total: 666 (members: 4, guests: 662)