Manning can't cut it in Bretts World

[agopackgo4]

pouring rain MIGHT have had an effect on some of them..but the few I did see S/D defense made outstanding plays on them

That's part of the game.
Rain, snow, never bothered Mr. Favre none.

Where did Brett play when he tossed 6 ints, and what was the weather?

That would be in St. Louis, in a dome? Playoffs...?

 

[longtimefan]

pouring rain MIGHT have had an effect on some of them..but the few I did see S/D defense made outstanding plays on them

That's part of the game.
Rain, snow, never bothered Mr. Favre none.

Where did Brett play when he tossed 6 ints, and what was the weather?

That would be in St. Louis, in a dome? Playoffs...?

See my previous post..

there was NO weather when he did it..

 

[Zombieslayer]

pouring rain MIGHT have had an effect on some of them..but the few I did see S/D defense made outstanding plays on them

That's part of the game.
Rain, snow, never bothered Mr. Favre none.

Where did Brett play when he tossed 6 ints, and what was the weather?

That would be in St. Louis, in a dome? Playoffs...?

See my previous post..

there was NO weather when he did it..

I'm not making an excuse for Favre.
He played a bad game.

My whole point is, you take Brett Favre and give him good WRs, look what he does.

You take P Manning and take away his all-star cast, look how he does.

The reason I brought up the weather had NOTHING to do with the 6 INTs. It had to do with Brett Favre being a bad weather QB. He plays games at home in freezing weather and snow every year. Doesn't bother him none. That's what I was saying.

 

[longtimefan]

I know what ya meant..

I said the pouring rain MIGHT have played a factor in Manning tossing 6 int, and the D making outstanding plays..

All that means is this..

I am not so sure I would put all the blame on the fact he was missing his normal WRs

 

[de_real_deal]

Last nights game against the Chargers gave the world a little glimpse at how the career of Peyton Manning would look if he had played is career in Brett Favre's shoes. In just one game without probowlers and future hall of famers surrounding him Manning looked awful. It makes you wonder what mannings stats would look like if he had played in green bay, and had recievers like robert brooks, bill shroder(i don't know how to speel it), and others of so so caliber who Brett made look better than they were.

I couldnt agree more.

 

[de_real_deal]

We're not saying he's not a good QB. Heck, I'll call him a great QB and a Hall of Famer, but he's no Brett Favre.

Agreed

 

[brennan1884]

hes no brett favre, and he never will be

 

[Zombieslayer]

Bump. We're seeing it now.

It wasn't just a one game fluke. If IND didn't have a kick *** D, they would have lost to KC at home.

In 2007, Brady is the NFL's best QB, Favre the second.

Take away Manning's all-star cast, he struggles.

Give Brady an all-star cast, he puts up better numbers than Manning with an all-star cast.

Give Favre depth, he'll kill you. Favre has depth now. We have five legit WRs and a solid TE. Look how many TDs he's thrown in the past few games.

As the title says - Manning can't cut it in Brett's world.

 

[de_real_deal]

Agreed

 

[CaptainItchy]

agreed whole heartedly