I ask this question because on this, and other Packer forums that I visit, there are some who put forth the argument that Favre should retire, is over-rated, is not a clutch QB when it counts, etc..etc..because his "record" in the playoffs is not that great--according to them. And these are Packer "fans" saying this...so I felt that I needed to address this question to the forum.
Is football a team sport?
The argument that Favre is not that good, or over-rated, goes like this. Favre's record is not that good in the playoffs, therfore he is an over-rated, not so good QB, and can not be compared to the elites in the game like Montana, Brady, etc.
My question to them is, what was John Elways record before he won those two SB's? Not very good. And he only won those SB's at the end of his career when he had a great team around him and he didn't have to do too much. Does that make him less of a great QB? Not in my book....
Favre brought teams to the playoffs that had no business being there, and when they lost against the better teams, it was no surprise.
My point is that people need to focus on the team as well as the QB when making these statements rather than just looking at stats and not taking the career of the individual (and the circumstances) into consideration....
It's not easy to win it all in the NFL.....just ask Dan Marino.
Is Dan Marino a lousy football player because he didn't win it all, or was he remarkable for doing incredible things with those subpar Dolphin teams..?
Is football a team sport?
The argument that Favre is not that good, or over-rated, goes like this. Favre's record is not that good in the playoffs, therfore he is an over-rated, not so good QB, and can not be compared to the elites in the game like Montana, Brady, etc.
My question to them is, what was John Elways record before he won those two SB's? Not very good. And he only won those SB's at the end of his career when he had a great team around him and he didn't have to do too much. Does that make him less of a great QB? Not in my book....
Favre brought teams to the playoffs that had no business being there, and when they lost against the better teams, it was no surprise.
My point is that people need to focus on the team as well as the QB when making these statements rather than just looking at stats and not taking the career of the individual (and the circumstances) into consideration....
It's not easy to win it all in the NFL.....just ask Dan Marino.
Is Dan Marino a lousy football player because he didn't win it all, or was he remarkable for doing incredible things with those subpar Dolphin teams..?