1. Welcome to Green Bay Packers NFL Football Forum & Community!

    Packer Forum is one of the largest online communities for the Green Bay Packers. You are currently viewing our community forums as a guest user.

    Sign Up or

    Having an account grants you additional privileges, such as creating and participating in discussions. Furthermore, we hide most of the ads once you register as a member!
    Dismiss Notice

Informal Forum Poll....Rank the NFL Coaches..!!

Discussion in 'Packer Fan Forum' started by P@ck66, Dec 7, 2005.

  1. P@ck66

    P@ck66 Banned Banned

    Joined:
    Jun 5, 2005
    Messages:
    2,207
    Ratings:
    +0
    How would you rank these coaches...(1- Best...32- Worst)

    (I was going to add..be honest..no homerism...musscy..but you beat me to it..!)

    AFC

    Mike Mularkey: Buffalo
    Nick Saban: Miami
    Bill Bellichik: Patriots
    Herman Edwards: Jets
    Brian Billick: Ravens
    Marvin Lewis: Bengals
    Romeo Crennel: Browns
    Bill Cowher: Steelers
    Dom Capers: Texans
    Tony Dungee: Colts
    Jack Del Rio: Jaguars
    Jeff Fisher: Titans
    Mike Shanahan: Broncos
    Dick Vermeil: Chiefs
    Norv Turner: Raiders
    Marty Shottenheimer: Chargers

    NFC

    Bill Parcells: Cowboys
    Tom Coughlin: Giants
    Andy Reid: Eagles
    Joe Gibbs: Redskins
    Lovey Smith: Bears
    Steve Mariucci: Lions
    Mike Sherman: Packers
    Mike Tice: Vikings
    Jim Mora: Falcons
    Jon Fox: Panthers
    Jim Haslett: Saints
    John Gruden: Bucs
    Denny Green: Cardinals
    Mike Martz: Rams
    Mike Nolan : 49ers
    Mike Holmgren: Seahawks
     
  2. musccy

    musccy Cheesehead

    Joined:
    Jun 5, 2005
    Messages:
    1,854
    Ratings:
    +1
    Re: Informal forum poll....

    I don't really feel that ranking is a an accurate way to look at coaches, rather, grade them. IHowever, I don't even like grading coaches, usually, since I can be as fickle as anyone, esp. w/ coaches I don't know much about. Anywho...

    DK = don't know



    AFC

    Mike Mularkey: Buffalo DK
    Nick Saban: Miami B
    Bill Bellichik: Patriots B
    Herman Edwards: Jets B
    Brian Billick: Ravens C
    Marvin Lewis: Bengals A
    Romeo Crennel: Browns B
    Bill Cowher: Steelers B
    Dom Capers: Texans DK
    Tony Dungee: Colts AB
    Jack Del Rio: Jaguars B
    Jeff Fisher: Titans B
    Mike Shanahan: Broncos B
    Dick Vermeil: Chiefs B
    Norv Turner: Raiders C
    Marty Shottenheimer: Chargers C

    NFC

    Bill Parcells: Cowboys AB
    Tom Coughlin: Giants AB
    Andy Reid: Eagles C
    Joe Gibbs: Redskins DK
    Lovey Smith: Bears B
    Steve Mariucci: Lions C
    Mike Sherman: Packers B
    Mike Tice: Vikings C
    Jim Mora: Falcons DK
    Jon Fox: Panthers AB
    Jim Haslett: Saints DK
    John Gruden: Bucs C
    Denny Green: Cardinals C
    Mike Martz: Rams DK
    Mike Nolan : 49ers DK
    Mike Holmgren: Seahawks B
     
  3. JbShell

    JbShell Cheesehead

    Joined:
    Nov 7, 2005
    Messages:
    796
    Ratings:
    +0
    Re: Informal forum poll....

    Mike Mularkey: Buffalo 20
    Nick Saban: Miami no rank first year
    Bill Bellichik: Patriots 3
    Herman Edwards: Jets 31
    Brian Billick: Ravens 32
    Marvin Lewis: Bengals 15
    Romeo Crennel: Browns 12
    Bill Cowher: Steelers 6
    Dom Capers: Texans 29
    Tony Dungee: Colts 1
    Jack Del Rio: Jaguars 10
    Jeff Fisher: Titans 21
    Mike Shanahan: Broncos 6
    Dick Vermeil: Chiefs 20
    Norv Turner: Raiders 28
    Marty Shottenheimer: Chargers 11

    Bill Parcells: Cowboys 13
    Tom Coughlin: Giants t-12
    Andy Reid: Eagles 16
    Joe Gibbs: Redskins 17
    Lovey Smith: Bears 8
    Steve Mariucci: Lions hes gone
    Mike Sherman: Packers t 20
    Mike Tice: Vikings 21
    Jim Mora: Falcons 17
    Jon Fox: Panthers t 3
    Jim Haslett: Saints gets a pass this year
    John Gruden: Bucs t 10
    Denny Green: Cardinals t 20
    Mike Martz: Rams he is out
    Mike Nolan : 49ers first year
    Mike Holmgren: Seahawks 5
     
  4. CaliforniaCheez

    CaliforniaCheez Cheesehead

    Joined:
    Apr 13, 2005
    Messages:
    2,486
    Ratings:
    +0
    Re: Informal forum poll....

    That's like ranking tools. Some times you need one, some times another.
     
  5. Miskito

    Miskito Cheesehead

    Joined:
    Jun 5, 2005
    Messages:
    377
    Ratings:
    +0
    Re: Informal forum poll....

    AFC

    26 Mike Mularkey: Buffalo
    20 Nick Saban: Miami
    7 Bill Bellichik: Patriots
    25 Herman Edwards: Jets
    17 Brian Billick: Ravens
    6 Marvin Lewis: Bengals
    16 Romeo Crennel: Browns
    5 Bill Cowher: Steelers
    32 Dom Capers: Texans
    2 Tony Dungee: Colts
    15 Jack Del Rio: Jaguars
    24 Jeff Fisher: Titans
    8 Mike Shanahan: Broncos
    9 Dick Vermeil: Chiefs
    29 Norv Turner: Raiders
    10 Marty Shottenheimer: Chargers

    NFC

    11 Bill Parcells: Cowboys
    12 Tom Coughlin: Giants
    18 Andy Reid: Eagles
    21 Joe Gibbs: Redskins
    3 Lovie Smith: Bears
    23 Steve Mariucci: Lions
    19 Mike Sherman: Packers
    27 Mike Tice: Vikings
    13 Jim Mora: Falcons
    4 Jon Fox: Panthers
    28 Jim Haslett: Saints
    14 John Gruden: Bucs
    30 Denny Green: Cardinals
    22 Mike Martz: Rams
    31 Mike Nolan: 49ers
    1 Mike Holmgren: Seahawks
     
  6. DePack

    DePack Cheesehead

    Joined:
    Jun 5, 2005
    Messages:
    3,904
    Ratings:
    +1
    Re: Informal Forum Poll....Rank the Coaches..!!

    Pack66 since I don't proclaim to be a coach expert I can't really rank them all but I will teel you where I think Sherman falls because I think that is what you are looking for.

    I would rank Sherman behind....Bellichek, Lewis, Cowher, Fisher, Shanahan, Parcels, Gibbs, Mooch(that's right!), Fox, Gruden and yes Holmy.

    I would rank Sherman in the same class as....Edwards, Dunghole, Vermeil, Shottenheimer, Reid, Mora and Green.

    I would rank Sherman ahead of.....Mularky, Saban(so far), Billick, Crennel, Capers, Del Rio, Turner, Coughlin, Smith, Tice, Haslett, Martz and Nolan.

    Which puts him in the 12-20 range. sorry...I can't get more accurate than that. Where do you rank him Pack?
     
  7. P@ck66

    P@ck66 Banned Banned

    Joined:
    Jun 5, 2005
    Messages:
    2,207
    Ratings:
    +0
    Re: Informal Forum Poll....Rank the Coaches..!!

    1. Bill Parcells: Dallas
    2. Joe Gibbs: Redskins
    3. Bill Bellichik: Patriots
    4. Mike Holmgren: Seahawks
    5. Mike Shanahan: Broncos
    6. Dick Vermeil: Chiefs
    7. Andy Reid: Eagles
    8. Jon Gruden: Bucs
    9. Jon Fox: Panthers
    10. Bill Cowher: Steelers
    11. Jeff Fisher: Titans
    12. Tony Dungy: Colts
    13. Marty Shottenheimer: Chargers
    14: Tom Coughlin: Giants
    15. Brian Billick: Ravens
    16. Marvin Lewis: Bengals
    17. Mike Martz: Rams
    18. Steve Mariucci: Lions
    19. Jim Mora: Falcons
    20. Lovie Smith: Bears
    21. Herman Edwards: Jets
    22. Jack Del Rio: Jaguars
    23. Denny Green: Cardinals
    24. Mike Tice: Vikings
    25: Mike Sherman: Packers
    26 Romeo Crennel: Browns
    27. Norv Turner: Raiders
    28. Jim Haslett: Saints
    29. Nick Saban: Dolphins
    30. Mike Mularky: Bills
    31. Mike Nolan: 49ers
    32. Dom Capers: Texans
     
  8. pantherd

    pantherd Cheesehead

    Joined:
    Jul 27, 2005
    Messages:
    118
    Ratings:
    +0
    Wow. Fox below Gruden? Dungy below Fox? Wow. Gibbs? We are talking about the present or recent past, not all-time right? Wow. That's a crime. Without Dungy, Gruden would have already been fired (i.e. he wouldn't have inheirited the SB team he walked in to). Without Dungy, Peyton and company would still be a good but not great team. Wow, that's all I can say. My list...


    1 - Bill Bellichik: Patriots (3 Super Bowls, 4 years...)
    2 - Tony Dungy: Colts (Would be vying for 2nd SB or more had TB not been stupid)
    3 - Andy Reid: Eagles (Gained respect for not taking T.O. crap and 4 NFCCs)
    4 - Marvin Lewis: Bengals (If you can win in Cincy... with a young QB...)
    5 - Jon Fox: Panthers (If you can get a 1-15 team to believe in themselves AND get the same 1-7 team to finish 6-2 a year later...)
    6 - Bill Cowher: Steelers (There's a reason Pitts has made him most tenured in the NFL)
    7 - Marty Shottenheimer: Chargers (He won in KC, he was better than his inheiritants in Wash, he's won in San Diego and made them a team to fear)
    8 - Bill Parcells: Dallas (Has turned around struggling franchises in NY - twice -, NE, and now Dallas)
    9 - Jack Del Rio: Jaguars (Sometimes the coach is better than the team)
    10 - Joe Gibbs: Redskins (Not as dominant the 2nd time around... the game's changed)
    11 - Herman Edwards: Jets (Straight forward, you know what you're getting)
    12 - Mike Shanahan: Broncos (Sometimes the team is better than the coach)
    13 - Mike Holmgren: Seahawks (Until he prooves that Sea ISN'T as soft as everyone thinks...)
    14 - Steve Mariucci: Lions (Won with old, washed up 49ers and Garcia. Scape goat in Detroit. Matt Millen is the problem)
    15 - Tom Coughlin: Giants (Hard nosed S.O.B.)
    16 - Lovie Smith: Bears (Others aren't laughing at this team quite so much any more).
    17 - Mike Sherman: Packers (From the outside looking in... this guy seems to suck, but that's just my opinion.)
    18 - Dick Vermeil: Chiefs (Loads of talent in KC, nothing to show for it)
    19 - Denny Green: Cardinals (Lots and lots of offensive talent. Still needs a running back, defense, and a consistent QB.)
    20 - Romeo Crennel: Browns (He's the right guy in a very bad situation.)
    21 - Norv Turner: Raiders (He's the wrong guy in a very bad situation.)
    22 - Jeff Fisher: Titans (How was this guy at the top of peoples list once upon a time?)
    23 - Nick Saban: Dolphins (Better off as a coordinator and/or college coach. He needs to heed the advice of Pete Carroll and dominate the little league for big pay checks.)
    24 - Jon Gruden: Bucs (Beneficiary of a stout Dungy D. Has since run the team into the ground with washed up veterans)
    25 - Jim Mora: Falcons (Dan Reeves got shafted with Vick's injury. Mora thrives on riding "Mike" Vick's jock.)
    26 - Brian Billick: Ravens (If only he were as good as he thinks he is...)
    27 - Dom Capers: Texans (Some guys are just destined to be great co-ordinators and aren't head coaches)
    28 - Mike Martz: Rams (See Dom Capers)
    29 - Mike Tice: Vikings (He, Dungy, and Spurrier were hired same year as John Fox. Glad the Panthers went the alternate route. Sure that Indy was happy with their guy too.)
    30 - Mike Nolan: 49ers (Giving the guy some credit... NO ONE could do much with this team.)
    31 - Mike Mularky: Bills (No other coach's name fits better. Bunch of Mularky.)
    32 - Jim Haslett: Saints (He's the wrong guy in ANY situation. This guy blows chunks.)
     
  9. DePack

    DePack Cheesehead

    Joined:
    Jun 5, 2005
    Messages:
    3,904
    Ratings:
    +1
    PAck66...Tice ahead of Sherman?
     
  10. P@ck66

    P@ck66 Banned Banned

    Joined:
    Jun 5, 2005
    Messages:
    2,207
    Ratings:
    +0
    DePack...

    (i thought you'd notice that..)

    But who has owned Sherman's *** in the last several appearances going back to the playoff game of last year?
     
  11. yourout

    yourout Cheesehead

    Joined:
    Aug 19, 2005
    Messages:
    352
    Ratings:
    +0
    Pack66.....I like your list. No way Edwards is ahead of Holmgren on pantherds list.
     
  12. P@ck66

    P@ck66 Banned Banned

    Joined:
    Jun 5, 2005
    Messages:
    2,207
    Ratings:
    +0
    thanks yourout...

    i think i should have up'd Edwards to 15..now that I think of it.....after Coughlin...

    He has done a pretty good job with the Jets the past few years...except he tends to be too conservative.....
     

Share This Page