I see Hodge on alot of overrated lists
Joseph Addai (not creative, doesn't bring much to the table)
Santonio Holmes (probably won't pan out)
Jimmy Williams (most likely to OD)
Mark Setterstrom (average)
Brandon Marshall (doesn't want it)
Dominique Byrd (weak little girl, #2 TE at best)
Dwayne Slay (special teamer)
Dale Robinson (special teamer)
Marcus McNeill (crippled)
DeMeco Ryans (nothing special)
Kai Parham (has nothing to offer)
Jonathan Joseph (no Mel, he's not a top 10 player)
Abdul Hodge (sloppy, may start someday but won't make plays)
Pat Watkins (not as good as advertised)
Charlie Whitehurst (3rd stringer/practice squad at best)
Andrew Whitworth (backup)
Jesse Mahelona (backup)
Kelly Jennings (nickelback)
Underrated:
Vernon Davis (should be consensus #1 pick)
DeAngelo Williams (wear and tear is a lame excuse, incredible runner)
DeMario Minter (incredible potential)
Tamba Hali (plays with tremendous intensity and focus)
Jon Scott (extremely productive career)
Kellen Clemens (intelligent and can get the job done)
Eric Winston (physical specimen, if healthy he's an outstanding PBer)
Darrell Hackney (wants it badly and has starting potential down the road)
Jon Alston (better than Ryans, intense and disciplined)
Tim Day (outstanding receiver)
Bernard Pollard (extremely productive, wants it)
Rocky McIntosh (exceptional athleticism and intangibles)
Derek Hagan (Mtl's "don't forget about me" award, awarded to Hagan)
Ko Simpson (still deserves to be a 1st rounder)
More
One of top ILB prospects in a weak class. Benefited, and may be overrated, because of the elite defensive players that he has played with in recent years (Matt Roth, Chad Greenway).
more
Ten Overrated Prospects
1. Charlie Whitehurst - QB - Clemson
Whitehurst is a big, strong-armed passer who is high on many lists but carries only a marginal starting grade here. He is not very accurate and his decision making has been suspect throughout his career. He probably will go in the top 100 selections but is a definite reach there.
2. Greg Eslinger – OC - Minnesota
This mobile senior was a four-year starter in the Big Ten and won numerous awards for his fine play. He is a sound technician with fine footwork but has only marginal size and short arms, which causes problems with big tackles in single assignments. He could surprisingly fall to the second day of the draft and is best suited for zone blocking schemes like the Falcons, Broncos and Vikings.
3. Thomas Howard – LB- UTEP
A fast, athletic linebacker who tests out as well as any prospect in this draft class, Howard's production was decent but did not match his athletic ability. His lack of big plays is a concern. His inability to initially read the play properly does not put him in a position to consistently make the impact play. His athleticism may get him selected in the top 50, but that would be a definite reach.
4. Parys Haralson – DE - Tennessee
Haralson is a quick, smallish edge rusher who had a fine final season and good Senior Bowl performance. He has marginal size for end in a 4-3 scheme and has rarely played standing up. He is quick off the ball - which allows him to win early on the down - but whether he can beat NFL-caliber tackles remains to be seen. He has struggled when top tackles get their hands on him early, and he fails to show good secondary moves.
5. Abdul Hodge – LB - Iowa
This tough, productive senior linebacker put up incredible tackle numbers over his Big Ten career. He is a savvy linebacker but did not impress at the NFL Combine like other highly regarded defenders. He carries a starting grade but is not a top-60 prospect, although he could be part of a run on linebackers on the first day.
6. Darrell Hunter – CB – Miami (Ohio)
A big, athletic cornerback who played at a fairly high level over his long career. His instincts and his ability to make the big play are suspect despite those numbers. He failed to impress at the Senior Bowl against top competition, though he tested out well at the NFL Combine. He will probably be selected in the first day of the draft, but his level of development is questionable and he will have to step up to compete for playing time even as a role defender.
7. Will Allen - OG - Texas
Allen is a big, physical guard who has been a stalwart on the Texas line over the past three years. He is only an average athlete and did not live up to his press clippings at the Senior Bowl or NFL Combine. He will fall to the late rounds as a result and carries only a marginal starting grade with development.
8. Michael Robinson – WR – Penn St.
This college quarterback will have to make a position switch to play at the next level. He has played running back and wideout but has not developed fully at any position - which will limit his early playing time. He has a long learning curve to compete for a starting job and will be limited to a role player as receiver and runner with the option to throw the ball. He may become a fine role player, but he will need some time to refine his skills and is not a top 150 prospect.
9. Kyle Williams - DT - LSU
A tough, sound technician who was a productive defender for the Tigers. He often got the most out of his average athleticism. His instincts and good functional strength allowed him to beat most college blockers. His marginal size and average athletic ability may hinder him as a pro. He likely be limited to only a backup role despite fine production in college.
10. Anwar Phillips – CB – Penn St.
Phillips is an agile cornerback who was part of the tough Penn State defense in recent years. He performed well in the Nittany Lions' system, playing mainly zone coverage over his career. He has good size but only marginal speed and athletic ability. He needs the right scheme to be effective. He can be exploited in man coverage, especially in the deep game where his recovery speed is suspect.
more
The OVERRATED Team
QB Vince Young Texas DE Manny Lawson N.C State
RB Brian Calhoun Wisconsin DE Tamba Hali Penn State
FB Matt Bernstein Wisconsin DT Rodrique Wright Texas
WR Santonio Holmes Ohio State DT Claude Wroten LSU
WR Hank Baskett New Mexico OLB DeMeco Ryans Alabama
TE Dominique Byrd USC OLB Spencer Havner UCLA
OT Winston Justice USC ILB Abdul Hodge Iowa
OT Andrew Whitworth LSU CB Ashton Youboty Ohio State
OG Taitusi Lutui USC CB Anwar Phillips Penn State
OG Will Allen Texas S Michael Huff Texas
C Greg Eslinger Minnesota S Greg Blue Georgia
I just can't believe we are talking about how many pro-bowls a 3rd round rookie LB is going to make. I mean last I checked we drafted AJ Hawk with the 5th pick overall. Hodge was a mid-round, and not even the best LB on the Iowa team. The guy will likely not even start a game this year.
Whats next, How many pro-bowls is Ingle Martin going to make? And then some idiots will come on here and vote for 9+ like Dan Marino..........arghhhh!!!!!!