ESPN Polls as of now
1-Montana
2-Elway
3-Manning
4-Marino
5-Favre
I agree on 1-2 but Manning has a lot more to prove to be in the top 5. How could Marino be ahead of Brett when he has a ring and is going to break all of his records.
My heart tells me he is definately top 5, but my head tells me he should realistically be somewhere in the 6-10 range all time.