Joe, Joe, Joe.......this sad story is not TT's issue, it is Brett's and Brett's alone. You may not like the decision to lose Favre, but at this point it is the only thing they can do.
Do I and all the other posters wish Favre were playing for us? You bet....if he would have witheld retirement and let the team know so they could make appropriate plans! That being said, the fact that he DID retire, and FORCED the team to move in a new direction...a direction headed by a young QB that had learned the system and was ready to go....creates issues that no team should have to endure.
It would be almost acceptable if the Packers did not have such a clearly defined succession plan at QB......but the FACT that AR was there, and the FACT that Favre knew he was ready to step in upon his exit make this an entirely different scenario. A scenario where I fall on the side of TT and MM.
Favre created this mess, and unfortunately he leaves someone else to take the hit. Complete ********!!
joe_smoe said:I as far as I'm concerned the lack of interest and desire packers fans had in wanting brett to come back serves them right. I hope he throws it in all the rogers supporters face!..Ted Thompson might be considered a good GM to most packers fans, but to me he is a disgrace and will forever regret the decision...
GO BRETT GO...I'll still be rooting for you!!!!
first thing that pissed me off about favre he didn't come out and actually be straight up and say packers I want to be back ... Then the organisation would of handled it differently ... What tt and mm say was answers to the speculation to medias ... What u want them to say if favre made a natinol retirement ...u want the team to say "oh were still after favre even tho he said I retire and tell everyone were not moving on cause Brett is only qb that could do it and rogers can't " no matter what tt or mm say were perfect they didnt screw up Brett favre did people time to wake up we have rogers release him ...don't waste time it will be to much distraction ... And if its only rumor even better for favrei dont think its that favre does not want to play for the packers, i think its that the packers dont want favre. hell, if i was in teds shoes i would be doing everything i can right now to make brett play again. the packers said that they would like to move on without favre. if he wants to play he has every right to play. dont blame him blame the organization. they are not showing any interest in wanting him back. would you want to play for a team that does not want you?
AR has not done anything to prove that he is ready to step in.
Joe, Joe, Joe.......this sad story is not TT's issue, it is Brett's and Brett's alone. You may not like the decision to lose Favre, but at this point it is the only thing they can do.
Do I and all the other posters wish Favre were playing for us? You bet....if he would have witheld retirement and let the team know so they could make appropriate plans! That being said, the fact that he DID retire, and FORCED the team to move in a new direction...a direction headed by a young QB that had learned the system and was ready to go....creates issues that no team should have to endure.
It would be almost acceptable if the Packers did not have such a clearly defined succession plan at QB......but the FACT that AR was there, and the FACT that Favre knew he was ready to step in upon his exit make this an entirely different scenario. A scenario where I fall on the side of TT and MM.
Favre created this mess, and unfortunately he leaves someone else to take the hit. Complete ********!!
pack_in_black said:Apparently, he has to the coaches and the FO staff. Otherwise they would've brought #4 in post haste.
Say what you will about our opinions of him, and the media and/or league officials opinions, but our coaches say AR is ready to play. And these events prove it more than their words. :shrug:
first thing that pissed me off about favre he didn't come out and actually be straight up and say packers I want to be back ... Then the organisation would of handled it differently ... What tt and mm say was answers to the speculation to medias ... What u want them to say if favre made a natinol retirement ...u want the team to say "oh were still after favre even tho he said I retire and tell everyone were not moving on cause Brett is only qb that could do it and rogers can't " no matter what tt or mm say were perfect they didnt screw up Brett favre did people time to wake up we have rogers release him ...don't waste time it will be to much distraction ... And if its only rumor even better for favreumair said:i dont think its that favre does not want to play for the packers, i think its that the packers dont want favre. hell, if i was in teds shoes i would be doing everything i can right now to make brett play again. the packers said that they would like to move on without favre. if he wants to play he has every right to play. dont blame him blame the organization. they are not showing any interest in wanting him back. would you want to play for a team that does not want you?
Here is the problem PIB
they THINK Rodgers can succeed
They KNOW Favre can succeed
Who do you want to captian our ship when it is so close to the ultimate port?
I am officially embarssed to be a Packers fan due to this board's reaction alone. This is pathetic.
The guy played 16 years for you, gave it his all. Played in GB year after year. Brought god knows how many FA's to GB. Played with broken bones and concussions. Had ONE losing season.
It's one thing to have the view that Rodgers is the future and you don't want Favre back. Thats a valid view and that is what the Packers are saying. Why are you saying these comments like "******" and "i will never forive you" and "don't let the door hit you on the way out", etc. People saying that are the most spoiled fans in the world. You got an unbelievable talent that played his whole career for you. He wanted to come back (BIG f'n deal - lots of athletes retire and come back - Strahan won a SB that way) and the Packers don't want him, so he's going somewhere else.
Michael Jordan played for the Wizards. Lombardi came back with the Redskins AFTER the Packers. This is unbelievable this reaction. Imagine if Elway retired, wanted to come back and the Broncos had moved on with Griese at the time (that worked out great btw) and the Broncos fans acting like this. This is absurd.
In the end, lets go Packers, AR whether all of us want him or not, is our QB. Let's go Packers and best of luck to Favre, I'll be cheering for you unless your playing the Packers.
Relax everyone. You hate him forever now because he changed his mind? WOW. And its not like he wanted ot play elsewhere, he wanted ot play for the Packers, they didn't want him.
pack_in_black said:Here is the problem PIB
they THINK Rodgers can succeed
They KNOW Favre can succeed
Who do you want to captian our ship when it is so close to the ultimate port?
While I get see your point, I don't know that Brett can. He's a year older, and only one year of the last how many? he's played a disciplined game. No guarantee that he'll play by MM's rules again. There was a lot of magic to get us to 13-3 last year, and it fizzled when Brett made that bad bad throw to Corey freakin Webster (and Al got blowed up all game).
If we bring Brett back now, Aaron won't play start a game in GB. He'll ask for a trade or release this year, and I would do the same. (speculation) So then, say we miss out again this year (any given sunday, esp. in the playoffs) and Brett calls it a career, no comeback, nothing. That leaves us with a shaky Brian Brohm as our starter and a huge ? for who knows how long @ QB. That's my thinking.
Furthermore, I will be upset if the Packers release him. way too much value just to release. Tell us who you want to play for Brett and we will work with those teams on a trade.