Krazygangsta
Cheesehead
The best solution i would think of would be trade AR ... get some good quality player for him ONLY IF Brett could guarantee us 2-3 more years just enough for Brohm to learn like rogers got the chance too
This is a good plan. Ted needs to use this plan.The best solution i would think of would be trade AR ... get some good quality player for him ONLY IF Brett could guarantee us 2-3 more years just enough for Brohm to learn like rogers got the chance too
Greg C. said:Sorry I'm getting sarcastic. I need to take a break from this site. There's nothing wrong with your post. I just don't think your suggestion would work.
bt_impaler said:How about you tell Rodgers and Favre to man up and compete for the position. It's not a negative to have two starting caliber QBs on the same roster. If their egos are too sensitive to even contemplate competing for the starting job, then I don't have much faith in either of them bringing another Superbowl to Green Bay.
Personally, I'd love to see Favre back, but he retired and in doing so passed the reins to Rodgers. Now that he wants to come back, he has to compete and prove that he deserves to be the starter again. You want the best team on the field at all times. Unless Favre doesn't think he's as good as Rodgers, I don't know what the problem is. Come back and prove yourself.
de_real_deal said:bt_impaler said:How about you tell Rodgers and Favre to man up and compete for the position. It's not a negative to have two starting caliber QBs on the same roster. If their egos are too sensitive to even contemplate competing for the starting job, then I don't have much faith in either of them bringing another Superbowl to Green Bay.
Personally, I'd love to see Favre back, but he retired and in doing so passed the reins to Rodgers. Now that he wants to come back, he has to compete and prove that he deserves to be the starter again. You want the best team on the field at all times. Unless Favre doesn't think he's as good as Rodgers, I don't know what the problem is. Come back and prove yourself.
Nah, its better to place all your eggs in one basket. Rodgers has plenty of experience. Almost 60 pass attempts already. More than enough to shut the door on a HOF qb who almost got us to the superbowl last year. Who the hell does Fav-re think he is anyway to change his mind. He thinks he's special i guess.
The best solution i would think of would be trade AR ... get some good quality player for him ONLY IF Brett could guarantee us 2-3 more years just enough for Brohm to learn like rogers got the chance too
bt_impaler said:How about you tell Rodgers and Favre to man up and compete for the position. It's not a negative to have two starting caliber QBs on the same roster. If their egos are too sensitive to even contemplate competing for the starting job, then I don't have much faith in either of them bringing another Superbowl to Green Bay.
Personally, I'd love to see Favre back, but he retired and in doing so passed the reins to Rodgers. Now that he wants to come back, he has to compete and prove that he deserves to be the starter again. You want the best team on the field at all times. Unless Favre doesn't think he's as good as Rodgers, I don't know what the problem is. Come back and prove yourself.
bt_impaler said:How about you tell Rodgers and Favre to man up and compete for the position. It's not a negative to have two starting caliber QBs on the same roster. If their egos are too sensitive to even contemplate competing for the starting job, then I don't have much faith in either of them bringing another Superbowl to Green Bay.
Personally, I'd love to see Favre back, but he retired and in doing so passed the reins to Rodgers. Now that he wants to come back, he has to compete and prove that he deserves to be the starter again. You want the best team on the field at all times. Unless Favre doesn't think he's as good as Rodgers, I don't know what the problem is. Come back and prove yourself.
Too logical, It wouldn't make sense to actually COMPETE for a job.
Favre wins - "he just got it cuz hes favre, they coddle him!"
Rodgers wins - "he didnt really win, they gave him the job cuz TT drafted him."
tromadz said:Favre wins - "he just got it cuz hes favre, they coddle him!"
Rodgers wins - "he didnt really win, they gave him the job cuz TT drafted him."
Isn't that what's happening now?
dd80forever said:tromadz said:Favre wins - "he just got it cuz hes favre, they coddle him!"
Rodgers wins - "he didnt really win, they gave him the job cuz TT drafted him."
Isn't that what's happening now?
not....at all. You might think its rodgers time cuz TT drafted him, but its rodgers time cuz ...they moved on cuz their previous QB retired, hinted at coming back but got cold feet, and wont go down that road again.
tromadz said:dd80forever said:tromadz said:Favre wins - "he just got it cuz hes favre, they coddle him!"
Rodgers wins - "he didnt really win, they gave him the job cuz TT drafted him."
Isn't that what's happening now?
not....at all. You might think its rodgers time cuz TT drafted him, but its rodgers time cuz ...they moved on cuz their previous QB retired, hinted at coming back but got cold feet, and wont go down that road again.
Um, that's the same thing. The so-called "Favre-Firsters" think Brett was ran out because of Ted's Ego
The, I guess so-called "TT supporters" think Favre crossed the line.
Who's right doesn't matter, The fact is it has divided fans, which is the exact same thing your scenario would do.
I think alot of this problem is because of Favre's ego.tromadz said:dd80forever said:tromadz said:Favre wins - "he just got it cuz hes favre, they coddle him!"
Rodgers wins - "he didnt really win, they gave him the job cuz TT drafted him."
Isn't that what's happening now?
not....at all. You might think its rodgers time cuz TT drafted him, but its rodgers time cuz ...they moved on cuz their previous QB retired, hinted at coming back but got cold feet, and wont go down that road again.
Um, that's the same thing. The so-called "Favre-Firsters" think Brett was ran out because of Ted's Ego
The, I guess so-called "TT supporters" think Favre crossed the line.
Who's right doesn't matter, The fact is it has divided fans, which is the exact same thing your scenario would do.
dd80forever said:bt_impaler said:How about you tell Rodgers and Favre to man up and compete for the position. It's not a negative to have two starting caliber QBs on the same roster. If their egos are too sensitive to even contemplate competing for the starting job, then I don't have much faith in either of them bringing another Superbowl to Green Bay.
Personally, I'd love to see Favre back, but he retired and in doing so passed the reins to Rodgers. Now that he wants to come back, he has to compete and prove that he deserves to be the starter again. You want the best team on the field at all times. Unless Favre doesn't think he's as good as Rodgers, I don't know what the problem is. Come back and prove yourself.
Too logical, It wouldn't make sense to actually COMPETE for a job.
You actually think They can compete and there wont be a riot afterwards?
Favre wins - "he just got it cuz hes favre, they coddle him!"
Rodgers wins - "he didnt really win, they gave him the job cuz TT drafted him."
You seem to live in this ideal world where the reality of ******** doesnt exist. Id love to live there.