Andy Reid deserves an F for the day. His choice at starting QB was out-done by his decisions to play Kolb and middle linebacker Bradley after both suffered concussions. Bradley looked like a punch drunk fighter after his collision and never should have been allowed to play.
The Eagles were generally disorganized on offense and their 10 penalties suggest they are an undisciplined team. Most of that is due to coaching.
Reid made McCarthy look like a genius in comparison. And Mike's personnel decisions and conservative play calling at the end nearly cost us the game. Lots of room for improvement---but a win when you play badly is a great win.
I agree, sending Kolb and Bradley out there after they knew they had concussions is inexcusable and could cause permanent damage (more than already has happened) and the league should send a letter to Reid about that. I'd be upset if it was my kid out there after a concussion even if it is the NFL. Talk about NOT protecting your players. Kolb came out on his own saying he couldn't see clearly. Why the hell was he allowed to go back out there. That's nuts.
I think the Eagles were aggressive which led to a lot of penalties, I'm not sure how much of that comes down to coaches. He might have told them, play loose with the rules cause we are at home and what not. I dunno.
As far as starting Kolb, to really win SBs in the league you have to have a pocket passer not a scrambler like Vick and I can see why they want to get Kolb up and running the offense. He supposedly has a big arm, but he was horrible against our D. I think that is a credit to the scheme Capers had in place. Wish we had a scheme for Vick as a backup and it was obvious we didn't.
The Eagles seem like a much better coached team than Dallas for instance. Reid is a pretty good coach, they've gotten to the Championship game 5 times in 10 years, you have to be a pretty good coach to do that. yeah, McCarthy's conservative approach in the 2nd half nearly cost us the game. That was just dumb and frustrating. Although if the offense had been able to get a few more 1st downs the could have run the clock out on them. Lets keep the pressure on all 4 quarters please.
Let's be glad we won.