Peyton is a lock to make the hall of fame as of right now as is Brady. You could interchange these two for one and two.
Polamalu over Brees is understandable. Troy has been 1 or 2 for many years now at his position. You could make a strong argument that Troy has been the best defensive player the past 5 years. Drew has had several good years and a SB but because of so many great QBs he wont be on that Manning Brady list.
Its not about Vick making it before Rodgers, its about who has done more at this time. As of right now Vick has more of a resume. When Rodgers has as many years in I hope his resume is much better and I assume it will be. But really its close now in the stats category and in a few years Rodgers will blow by him.
I dont think people realize that this list is as of right now. Not taking into consideration what might happen in the future. ESPN did something like this years ago and did a point system. Obviously it weighs heavy on years played over a few great years.
