Pack93z
You retired too? .... Not me. I'm in my prime
Pack93z said:the 2 to one TD to INT ratio that he owns.. none of that speaks HOF
Don't think I'm trolling you (as in fact I agree McNabb has a lot more to do to prove HOF worth) but just so we're on board: a 2:1 TD ratio is FANTASTIC.
The only HOF QBs with 2:1 TD to INT ratios are Montana (by a tiny margin) and Young (who was the most proficient QB ever in terms of QB rating, TD/INt ratio). Peyton Manning is on his way as well.
But other HOF QBs... like Elway, Marino, Aikman and even going way back to Otto Graham and Johnny Unitas... not even close to 2:1 ratio.
And Favre won't be close either.
I agree that it is a good number.. hard to obtain no doubt but not worthy of carrying him to the hall of fame.. Jeff Garcia is like a 1.9 to 1 ratio.. is he a HOF QB?
Again he is a good QB.. one of the best in the league when healthy.. but he isn't an all-time elite player... pro-bowl QB at times in his career.. but so was Tony Romo.. Mike Vick.. and the list goes on...