Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Stanger37" data-source="post: 819221" data-attributes="member: 13457">I think the whole idea of getting to challenge penalties opens up a can of worms that the NFL isn't going to want to do. Unless someone already painted this scenario and explained, I didn't read all 6 pages. So sorry in advance if repeating someone.So coach challenges an offensive PI call. Refs get in a huddle and go under the hood. Upon reviewing to see if it was in fact offensive PI, there is a blatant hold/hands to the face on the offensive line that was missed. They already show replays of the plays to the stadium so everyone is going to see it clear as day. So do you just ignore that missed call? And then what if it wasn't PI? Do you give the coach his challenge back because he we technically won, it wasn't PI but there was another penalty and do they enforce that now? Or do you ignore that call because that isn't a 'challenge eligible' penalty? And now coaches are mad that they missed that call and didn't do anything about it.If they're trying to simplify football to limit the amount of "WTFs?!" challenging penalties isn't going to help. I think it sounds better on paper than it would actually play out. Certainly could be wrong.</blockquote>

No members online now.

Total: 469 (members: 0, guests: 469)