RE: Top 10 Cornerback thread (oops)

sorry folks.

i deleted the shadow topic in the Packer forum and it deleted the real one as well.

apologies to everybody involved that put some thought into their posts.

once again, sorry guys!

thanks arrow! Actually its not really a big deal
well this is what i was going to post if anyone still cares (some parts might not make sence w/o the other posts)

no offence Joker but you listed McGee and not Al Harris that is stupid. I am live in Western NEw York and am a Bills fan after the PAckers and Terrence McGee is no top 20 CB or howevermany you had. How can you say he is better than Al Harris? McGee is a great returner and an okay CB making him a pretty valuable player but not top 20 CB good.

Here is my list but don't bash me if they are horrible because i am co CB genius:
1.Champ Bailey
2. Ty Law
3. Patrick Surtain
4. Nate Clements
5. Chris McAilister
6. Antoine Winfield
7. Marcus Trufant
8. Dre Bly
9. Ronde Barber
10. DeAngelo Hall

thats a second thread deleted by mods for no good reason within a couple of weeks....

tsk tsk tsk tsk

Im not bashing u but Ty Law is no longer the second best CB. If he was dont you think he would have a job?

1. Champ Bailey
2. Nate Clements
3. Chris McAlister
4. Ronde Barber (very underrated)
5. DeAngelo Hall (solid and has upside)
6. Antoine Winfield
7. Patrick Surtain
8. Dre Bly
9. Al Harris
10. Dunta Robinson

Honorable Mentions: Ty Law, Ken Lucas, Lito Sheppard, Chris Gamble (great upside), Shawn Springs, and Terrance Newman.

That's off the top of my head so sorry if I missed anyone.

Edit: I think Woodson falls in the top 20 somewhere.

hey you...shut up!

I never said he was better, Tom, and I even made it clear I didn't rank any of them.

Thank you for paying attention, and thank you arrow for deleting every thread I attempt to post on. I'm out.

AHHHH, honestly you good for nothing mod, can't you do anything right?

lol don't worry arrow, ish happens.

I will post mine again. No big deal Arrow.


1. Bailey
2. Clements
3. Ty Law
4. Surtain
5. DeAngelo Hall
6. Chris McAlister
7. Winfield
8. Harris
9. Robinson
10 Marcus Trufant



I missed Jokers list. Can anyone update me on what it looked like

Ty Law, in my opinion, is the most overrated corner in the league. Out of his 10 interceptions, about 7 of them were gifts that fell right into his lap. I also recall him getting beat quite a few times. There's a reason why no one is paying this guy the 10 mill a year he's asking for

You mod's really mess up a lot lol (hehe )

Props for owning up to it and taking responsability when you do not have to!

1 thread.

relax, accidents happen.

I agree 100% He used to be amazing, but isn't anymore. It seems like last year he got burned way more than he did anything good. He got a bunch of interceptions that didn't really matter in the long run because the team was awful and he seems to feel that interceptions are more important than covering your guy. I would rather have a corner that can shut down the reciever he is up against and have no interceptions than a corner that gets a bunch of interceptions but gets beat on a very regular basis.

You better get used to this guy for the next ten year or so.
In his first two seasons he has 13 picks. That is one less than Al Harris has in 8 seasons.



Nathan Vasher

If you are getting a ton of picks you are usually giving up a ton of TD's after your first couple years. QB's don't throw much to receivers covered by real shut down corners. My guess is if Vasher is the real deal (and I'm not saying he isn't) his ints will drop off significantly.

He left the Bears facility pissed about the Bears not re-doing his contract. Watch the guy have a fallout with the Bears this year and be the next holdout (a la Mike McKenzie)...

ray:

GOOD POINT!

Couldn't have said it better mah self!

Zero....check that last post. That was me, DePack. Careful.......you keep saying things like you'll be crossing over into the darkside.

LoL Nah No worries bro. You had a good point. I tell it how it is, simple is at that. Some can handle it, some can't.




oh btw i AM the darkside

Phil, I was going to post the same thing. They can call it Bears fan homerism, but in my opinion Vasher has all the potential to be one of the best ever.

Chi Bears #31 is already in HOF.

LOL, It won't happen, he's only missed some "Voluntary" workouts, no big deal. :wink:

True, true.

I also like Vasher. I don't think he'll be one of the best ever (Darrell Green, Deion Sanders type) but I think he'll be great. I thought he was a steal in round 4 when he was picked. I loved him at Texas. So underrated entering the Draft. Great pick by the Bears and it's showing.